ChurchMilitantTV removes comments : irrational theology which David Obeid and Luke Macik have to teach to be approved by the bishop

Church Militant TV Staff have removed two comments from Mic'd Up : Catholic School Daze 1

This was one of the comments.

 

Church Militant TV could begin to resolve this issue by identifying the irrational premise, inference and conclusion.

This error is the basis of the new ecclesiology which is being taught at Catholic Schools in Detroit, where CMTV is situated.This error is also being taught by Fr.Joseph D.Fessio,Editor at Ignatius Press, David Obeid, Principal of St. Mary Mackillop Colleges, Australia and Luke Macik, Headmaster of the Lyceum Academy,USA .They appeared on the last Mic'd Up program ' The School Daze'.They have not denied this error in the comments section. 2 David Obeid is a recognised apologist whose work I appreciate.

SSPX must continue to reject Vatican Council II and other magisterial documents interpreted with the false premise and conclusion : ChurchMilitant TV comment incomplete

http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2015/04/sspx-must-continue-to-reject-vatican.html

Ryan Fitzgerald, Simon Rafe and the Church Militant TV Staff will not discuss this issue with specifics. They cannot get technical. They cannot cite doctrine or  logic to support any view. So instead of assisting with the CDF-Reconciliation they knock off comments.

 

DAVID OBEID, LUKE MACIK AGREE

The other comment which was removed mentioned that David Obeid, Principal of St. Mary Mackillop Colleges, and Luke Macik, Headmaster of the Lyceum Academy have no denial to issue. They agree that it is irrational to assume that the baptism of desire and being saved in invincible ignorance are explicit exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.

They also agree that there are no magisterial documents before 1949 which state that these cases are personally known to us in the present times to be exceptions to the dogma or that they were exceptions.

This is all inferred wrongly by the contemporary Magisterium and is supported by the bishops in Australia and the USA.

This is the irrational theology which David Obeid and Luke Macik have to teach at their Catholic educational institutions, to not have the name Catholic removed  and be approved by the bishop.

It is this irrational theology which the SSPX has to accept to receive full canonical status.It is endorsed by Ryan Fitzgerald and Simon Rafe.It has the blessings of the Church hierarchy in Detroit where Church Miltant TV is located.

-Lionel Andrades