Saturday, July 16, 2016

In faith we part

On Church Militant TV's 'The Download-The Theological Virtues-Faith' there is no reference to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS) since perhaps Michael Voris and the CMTV team did not want to be considered 'schismatic' doctrinally.They refer to 'the theological virtue of faith'.Theologically,  EENS with no exceptions is the traditional faith, and EENS with exceptions is the contemporary faith.
The Vortex,On Being Saved was about faith without any reference to the new theology.So it was EENS without known exceptions.
On the Friday Download it says non Christians do not have supernatural faith and Catholics do have supernatural faith.
Why could CMTV not say that according to the dogma EENS and Vatican Council II, non Christians do not have faith?
Their approach on the On Being Saved video was good  but there was no reference to EENS or Vatican Council II(LG 14, AG 7).
The Arcchdiocese of Detroit and the Sacred Heart Seminary,Detroit interpret EENS according to the contemporary magisterium.So do the  liberals and heretics.
Doctrinally it is a break with the pre-Council of Trent magisterium.So as not to be considered schismatic by them CMTV does not mention EENS?
Heresy cannot be faith.
Catholic faith cannot be changed by the contemporary magisterium.
CMTV has a ding-dong, back and forward, prudent position on faith.
Since theologically faith has changed in the Catholic Church,we now have a new faith and those who do not accept it are doctrinally wrong, schismatic,not worthy of canonical status.
So Michael Voris compromises by accepting Vatican Council II with the new faith.
And at the same time he says all need to enter the Church for salvation.
So if he attends Mass ad orientem or facing the people, it still is with the new faith.
This Download presents the new faith, theologically, by so much of what it does not say.
So the SSPX is in doctrinal schism, for the CMTV, for not accepting the Sacred Heart Seminary's new faith, with EENS having known exceptions.
CMTV is not in doctrinal schism since it accepts EENS and Vatican Council II with the new faith; there are exceptions to EENS in Vatican Council II.Both are O.K with magisterial heresy.
In which category does Bradley Eli at the Download, place me? I accept EENS with no exceptions and Vatican Council II does not have exceptions to EENS for me.Since in my faith, Lumen Gentium 16 is implicit, invisible  and not hypothetical. 
For Dr. Robert Fastiggi, professor of theology at the Sacred Heart seminary and for the Archbishop of Detroit, Lumen Gentium 16 is explicit and not hypothetical. This is their faith.
So doctrinally my faith and that of the theology professor is different.What does CMTV Download have to say about this. Dr.Fastiggi considers himself a Catholic and so do I. We both have faith but it is not the same faith.
-Lionel Andrades

No comments: