This passes of for Catholic philosophical reasoning.It is the philosophical basis of a new Catholic theology.It is accepted by all the signatories of the Lake Garda Statement.There would have been no 'Conciliar changes' without this error

Dr. John Rao lecture: “Even Now the Devastation Is Begun"

Dr. John Rao (shown in the video reading the Lake Garda Statement) 

http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2016/08/dr-john-rao-lecture-even-now.html#more

Introduction

Only eleven years before the commencement of the Second Vatican Council, Pope Pius XII issued a prophetic admonition. Speaking of the long history of the Church’s members “using every endeavor to convert their fellow citizens to the religion of Jesus Christ and to fashion their morals according to its pattern, so as to safeguard both religion and the state from approaching danger,” Pius XII urged a renewal of missionary activity in the face of the rising specter of a civilizational apostasy and its fatal consequences...

Pius XII’s assessment, in line with that of his predecessors in the Church’s long confrontation with the errors of modernity, was abruptly abandoned after the Council in favor of the now prevailing “conciliar optimism” regarding what Gaudium et spes described as the “current trend of the world...”

An ill-defined ecumenism promotes what Pope Pius XI called “a most grave error, by which the foundations of the Catholic faith are completely destroyed”---meaning the idea that Christian unity no longer requires “the return to the one true Church of Christ of those who are separated from it”]­—as if membership in the Catholic Church no longer mattered for the salvation of souls. A perpetual process of “dialogue” replaces the Church’s forthright proclamation of the necessity of conversion to the one true religion for both human flourishing in this life and eternal happiness in the life to come. Along with these developments, an unprecedented liturgical reform devised by a committee has ended with what Cardinal Ratzinger  called “the collapse of the liturgy” and later, as Pope Benedict XVI, the “banalization of the liturgy.”- Dr.John Rao, The Lake Garda Statement.

 Pius XII urged a renewal of missionary activity in the face of the rising specter of a civilizational apostasy and its fatal consequences...

Lionel:

There should be a renewal of missionary activity but Pope Pius XII, the SSPX bishops and the Lake Garda statement signatories have made an error. Dr.John Rao and the other traitionalists today wronly assume hypothetical cases are not hypothetical.They have made this error in principle.

They suggest theoretical cases of the baptism of desire, allegedly without the baptism of water etc are not theoretical.Since they are exceptios to the Feneyite interpretation of the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS Feeneyite).

Since there is known salvation outside the Catholic Church why should there be  missionary activity for the Lake Garda seminar participants?
They have discarded EENS ( Feeneyite).
Instead they have replaced it with a new doctrine EENS ( Cushingite).

Since hypothetical cases of the baptism of desire are visible to be exceptions to EENS( Feneeyite) they now have an EENS ( Cushingite) i.e EENS with exceptions.

Unlike them I affirm EENS ( Feeneyite).
So I know all non  Catholics are oriented to Hell with no exceptions.So Catholic mission is important since there are no theological exceptions for me.


Every year I keep saying the same thing but they do not understand or they do not want to respond.

______________________________

An ill-defined ecumenism promotes what Pope Pius XI called “a most grave error, by which the foundations of the Catholic faith are completely destroyed”---meaning the idea that Christian unity no longer requires “the return to the one true Church of Christ of those who are separated from it”[9]­—as if membership in the Catholic Church no longer mattered for the salvation of souls.

Lionel: Yes.Since for Dr. John Rao theologically there are known exceptions to the dogma EENS ( Feeneyite).Every one does not need to be a card carrying member of the Church.Every one does not need to have his name on the Parish Baptismal Register to avoid Hell.

So there is a new ecumenism. Why should Christians have to be members of the Catholic Church when Dr. John Rao, Chris Ferrara and John Vennari assume there is known salvation outside the Church with the baptism of desire and blood  and being saved in invincible ignorance?

Yes, they need to affirm EENS( Feeneyite) and not EENS ( Cushingite).

It reminds me of Fr.John Zuhlsdorf.He says he does not affirm the hard line position of Fr.Leonard Feeney.At the same time he says we must affirm the dogma EENS. He's probably referring to a new version of EENS, EENS Cushingite.He assumes EENS( Cushingite) is the dogma EENS according to the Church Councils, popes and saints!

So for the Lake Garda seminar participants there is a replacment-doctrine.As it is there for the SSPX and the other traditionalists. There is EENS( Cushingite),Vatican Council II( Cushingite), ecumenism( Cushingite) etc etc.They add a false premise and conclusion in the interpretation of  magisterial teachings.This is why there is no mission and no ecumenism of return.

I affirm the Nicene Creed ( Feeneyite), Vatican Council II( Feneeyite), the Catechism of the Catholic Church ( Feeneyite) and Letter of the Holy Office 1949( Feeneyite)-all without the false premise and conclusion.

Along with these developments, an unprecedented liturgical reform devised by a committee has ended with what Cardinal Ratzinger  called “the collapse of the liturgy”[10] and later, as Pope Benedict XVI, the “banalization of the liturgy.”

Lionel: The New Theology which Pope Benedict supported is based on the lie, the irrationality, which created a new doctrine. It is the basis of Cushingism.It has created a new ecclesiology for the Traditional Latin Mass and the Novus Ordo Mass.

Pope Benedict a few months back in the interview with Avvenire said EENS is no more like it was at the time of the 16th century missionaries.Since he interprets EENS ( Feeneyite) with the New Theology.It is with irrational Cushingism, in which hypothetical statements are considered to be non hypothetical.

So there is no Vatican Council II(EENS) for Pope Benedict XVI.Instead there is a Vatican Council II Cushingite.Since there is ' development of doctrine' for him, when hypothetical references are assumed to be objectively known in the present times.

This passes of for Catholic philosophical reasoning.It is the philosophical basis of a  new Catholic theology.It is accepted by all the signatories of the Lake Garda Statement.There would have been no 'Conciliar changes' without this error.

-Lionel Andrades

http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2015/07/the-lake-garda-statement.html