Monday, November 21, 2016

So what if the SSPX may be recognized today by Pope Francis? Like the Vatican Curia and the St. Benedict Centers they will be interpreting Vatican Council II with Rahenerian theology. So the Council will emerge as a break with Tradition.

So what if the SSPX may be recognized today by Pope Francis? Like the Vatican Curia and the St. Benedict Centers they will be interpreting Vatican Council II with Rahenerian theology. So the Council will emerge as a break with Tradition.
There is an option and I use it. Vatican Council II is then not a rupture with the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus and the Syllabus of Errors.
Rahnerian theology is based on an irrationality. It is bad philosophy. The Letter of the Holy Office 1949 made the original mistake.It was incorporated into Vatican Council II and was accepted by Cardinal Ratzinger, Fr. Karl Rahner, Archbishop Lefebvre, the SSPX bishops and the religious at the St. Benedict Centers, the communities of Fr. Leonard Feeney in the USA.
So when they offer or attend the Traditional Latin Mass it is with the new theology, based on hypothetical cases not being hypothetical but defacto known in the present times.What is invisible is considered visible.This results in a break with the old ecclesiology on which depended an ecumenism of return, outside the Church there being no salvation for Jews, Muslims etc and the non separation of Church and State with Jesus and the Church being a priority over all politcal and social legislation.This is all eliminated.It is eliminated  with the premise of there being known salvation outside the Church.
If we avoid this premise then LG 16, LG 8, NA 2 would no more refer to visible cases. They would not be exceptions or relevant to the dogma EENS.
However for the St. Benedict Centers and the SSPX, Lumen Gentium 16 etc are exceptions to the dogma EENS. So the traditionalists infer that LG 16 etc are physically known in the present times. This is irrational but this is their offical Rahnerian position.

So if the SSPX is recognised by the Vatican what difference would it make ? Both groups are still not interpreting Vatican Council II in harmony with the Feeneyite interpretation of the dogma EENS.There still is a rupture with rationality.-Lionel Andrades

No comments: