Monday, May 1, 2017

Pope Benedict's magisterial heresy is 'a guide for the perplexed' for Tracey Rowland

Image result for Photo The magisteriumTracey Rowland, Fr.John Zuhlsdorf and Bishop Robert Morlino, bishop in the diocese of Madison,USA are 'doing theology' with Cushingism instead of Feeneyism.

This was the head line of a blog post  last Monday on EucharistandMission ( April 24,2017).

I e-mailed this post to Tracey Rowland and also got the message across to Bishop Morlino and his diocese offices.

It is there on Fr. John Zuhlsdorf's Twitter page.May this is still new for them and they are studying it.

Benedict XVI: A Guide for the Perplexed (Guides for the Perplexed)
 Ratzinger's Faith: The Theology of Pope Benedict XVI
The Australian theologian Tracey Rowland, a liberal, who is  highly recommended by Fr.Zuhlsdorf has written a book on Pope Benedict XVI,
Benedict XVI: A Guide for the Perplexed (London: T & T Clark, 2010).
Theologically, Pope Benedict like his friends Rahner, Kung and Kasper is anything but a guide for the perplexed.Instead he has created and sustained most of the confusion and magisterial heresy in the Church. He has contributed to and defended a false and deceptive new theology in the Catholic Church which is acceptable for Tracey Rowland.
Yesterday in a blog post 1 I mentioned:
One year earlier in March 2016 Pope Benedict XVI undermined the Church's teachings on faith and salvation.He did not interpret the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS) with the traditional and common sense theology of Feeneyism.Instead he chose an irrational and innovative Cushingite theology.It made the dogma EENS a rupture with Vatican Council II. So for the pope and the CDF, there is no Vatican Council II and EENS , Feeneyite.Instead there is  something new.It is Vatican Council II and EENS, Cushingite.
Image result for Photo Nicene Creed
So the Nicene Creed and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Catechism of Pope Pius X,Catechism of the Council of Trent, Baltimore Catechism and other catechisms would have to be re-interpreted. They would be re-interpreted with hypothetical cases not being hypothetical.Invisible baptism of desire would be considered physically visible.Any reference to being saved in invincible ignorance would be a reference to a personally known case to someone.
Personally not identified cases of people allegedly being saved without the baptism of water in the past centuries would be postulated as explicit exceptions to the dogma EENS in the present times (2017).So St. Emerentiana and St. Victor of the past would be objective exceptions to all needing to be members of the Catholic Church in the present times (2917).Irrational? Fantasy theology? Yes.But it is magisterial. Pope Benedict said so in public.
This is public heresy.
He also contradicts the Oath Against Modernism. He has done away with the Oath and is a modernist on this issue.Summorum Pontificium permits the Traditional Latin Mass to be offered - but only with modernism, only with the theology of Cushingism. 
On April 18,2017 I wrote that Pope Benedict  during his liturgy contradics the Oath Against Modernism.2 It was mentioned:
Last March 2016, Pope Benedict XVI, in the daily Avvenire stated, that extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS) was no more like it was for the 16th century missionaries. He said that the dogma had evolved with Vatican Council II.1 He meant  Vatican Council II ( Cushingism) assumed there are visible and known exceptions to the dogma EENS and he accepts this. So for him there is salvation outside the Church. LG 16, LG 8, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22, unlike for me, would refer to physically visible and known cases for Pope Benedict. This is modernism.He has changed the Catholic identity.Pope Benedict XVI during his liturgy contradicts the Oath Against Modernism.The same modernism is supported by the Society of St. Pius X and sedevacantist bishops and priests who have had their formation under Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre.It is modernism during their liturgy.
The Oath Against Modernism is now meaningless. Even Bishop Athanasius Schneider who has called for a Syllabus of Errors on Vatican Council II, interprets Vatican Council II with Cushingism instead of Feeneyism.He is a modernist at the Traditional Latin Mass.
This is modernism and heresy coming from 'top to down'.It was enforced by Pope Benedict throughout the Church.He did it as the cardinal-prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith during the pontificate of an ailing pope and then as the pope himself.
Tracey Rowland, Fr. John Zuhlsdorf and Bishop Morlino follow this false theology. It is taught to the seminarians in the diocese of Madison,Wisconsin where Fr.Zuhlsdorf recommends  a book written by Rowland.He has sent it to the seminarians.


They need to clarify that Pope Benedict XVI made a mistake in March 2016 when he stated in Avvenire that extra ecclesiam nulla salus was no more like it was for the 16th century missionaries. He said that there was a development with Vatican Council II.He meant Vatican Council II interpreted with Cushingism.He did not mention Vatican Council II and EENS being interpreted with Feeneyism.


The position of Pope Benedict and Pope Francis on this issue is heretical. They interpret Vatican Council II and the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus with the theology of Cushingism.They do this even when they have a choice.It is the same with Tracey Rowland, Fr. John Zuhlsdorf and Bishop Morlino.

So Pope Benedict is no guide for the perplexed.

They need to interpret magisterial documents with rational Feeneyism and reject irrational Cushingism.There is only one interpretation of Vatican Council II.With Cushingism Vatican Council II can be interpreted in two ways and there is confusion.


Image result for Photos Letter of the Holy Office 1949

Feeneyism: It is the old theology and philosophical reasoning which says there are no known exceptions past or present, to the dogma EENS.There are no explicit cases to contradict the traditional interpretation of EENS.

 Cushingism: It is the new theology and philosophical reasoning, which assumes there are known exceptions, past and present, to the dogma EENS, on the need for all to formally enter the Church.It assumes that the baptism of desire etc are not hypothetical but objectively known.In principle hypothetical cases are objective in the present times.


Pope Benedict is in heresy on a de fide teaching of the Church.There is a rupture between his faith and reason.He may say that he accepts the dogma EENS but he refers to a Cushingite EENS.This is a new doctrine.It is  a rupture with the dogma EENS as it was known to the missionaries in the 16th century. He frankly disclosed this in public.
He was saying that his magisterium contradicted the magisterium of the 16th century.Is this not heresy? Boldly and bluntly he said this and no one in March 2016 asked if a pope can be in heresy and reject an infallible teaching of the past.
Pope Benedict has used philosophical subjectivism in salvation theology and has no objections to the same subjectivism in Amoris Laetitia. 
Image result for Photo magisterial heresyImage result for Photos Letter of the Holy Office 1949
Tracey Rowland is Dean and Associate Professor of Political Philosophy and Continental Theology of the John Paul II Institute, Melbourne, Australia, and Member of the Centre of Theology and Philosophy at the University of Nottingham.
She earned her doctorate in philosophy from Cambridge University and her Licentiate in Sacred Theology from the Pontifical Lateran University in Rome. 
Another blurb says  Professor Tracey Rowland is the St John Paul II Chair in Theology at the University of Notre Dame (Australia). She is also a member of the International Theological Commission(ITC)Vatican which officially uses Cushingite theology.
Image result for Photo magisterial heresy
The ITC theology is based on the Letter of the Holy Office 1949 to the Archbishop of Boston relative to Fr.Leonard Feeney which Karl Rahner placed in the Denzinger and Joseph Ratzinger referenced in the Catechism of the Catholic Church(1995) and which was supported by Cardinal Walter Kasper, as President of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Vatican.-Lionel Andrades

 APRIL 18, 2017


APRIL 30, 2017

Conference speakers and others can still now, ' one year after Amoris Laetitia' , 'seek clarity' on the heretical statement of Pope Benedict last March 2016.


Pope Benedict XVI during his liturgy contradicts the Oath Against Modernism


Marching on in March -3


Hello April 2017 -2

Image result for Photo April

No comments: