"What do you think that Jesus was doing when He was proclaiming the Gospel? Making Catholics?" That's exactly what He was doing. What do you think He was doing, making them feel good? If that's what He was doing, then the Son of God failed miserably, because they killed Him for what He was saying. Of course He was making Catholics. He established a Church and then commanded the first leaders of that Church to go out and teach. He also told those first leaders that they would be martyred for teaching the truth.