Tuesday, July 25, 2017

Bishop Athanasius Schneider does not respond to e-mails or reports on the Internet : Pope Francis has made an objective mistake and violates the Principle of No Contradiction in the interpretation of Vatican Council II

Image result for Photo of Bishop Athanasius Schneider hiding the truth

Bishop Athanasius Schneider will still not say that Pope Francis has made an objective mistake and violates the Principle of No Contradiction in the interpretation of Vatican Council II and other magisterial documents even after I have e-mailed him and there are numerous reports on the Internet.He is protecting himself. Soon he will issue another report on the Internet  or do an interview on the subject of Vatican Council II.He will interpret the Council with the same irrational premise. He will choose Vatican Council II Cushingite instead of Feeneyite, since this is expected him of him by the Vatican.
He calls upon Catholics to proclaim the truth but he will not do it since it could be an expensive sacrifice to make.
His statements otherwise on Vatican Council II are vague and politically accommodating. He will say there is salvation in only the Catholic Church but will not say that there are no exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS).He will not affirm Feeneyite EENS since invisible baptism of desire is a visible exception for him, to the strict interpretation, as it was known in the 16th century.
He is a modernist on this sensitive issue while he otherwise  criticizes modernism in the Catholic Church.
“We are living in a very special time of a deep crisis of faith inside the Church,” said Bishop Athanasius Schneider, the Auxiliary in the diocese of Maria Santissima in Kazakhstan, who opens the video, produced by LifeSiteNews and yet he will not say that Pope Francis has made an objective mistake and violates the Principle of No Contradiction in the interpretation of Vatican Council II and other magisterial documents 
Cardinal Burke and Bishop Athanasius Schneider accept the Letter of the Holy Office 1949 which made the objective mistake. It mixed up invisible cases as being visible.This determines how they and the popes interpret Vatican Council II.If they would believe that Cardinal Richard Cushing and not Fr.Leonard Feeney was in heresy in 1949 then the interpretation of Vatican Council II changes.
If Cardinal Cushing was wrong to assume there are known exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus then Vatican Council II is traditional and has the old ecclesiology.Since there would no be exceptions mentioned in Vatican Council II to the dogma EENS as it was known to the 16th century missionaries.
Presently Cardinal Burke and Bishop Schneider both reject Feeneyism which says, according to me, that there are no known exceptions to the dogma EENS.For them there are exceptions!
For them the baptism of desire and being saved in invincible ignorance refer to known people saved without the baptism of water.So LG 16 etc becomes an  objective and known exception to the dogma EENS, even though there are no such cases on earth.Vatican Council II becomes a rupture with Tradition because of their personal irrationality and not because of the text of the Council.
The Letter of the Holy Office 1949 assumed that imaginary cases of the baptism of desire etc were not imaginary. This same error in reasoning is made by Cardinal Burke and Bishop Athansius Schneider.
Bishop Athanasius Schneider has called for a Syllabus of Errors on Vatican Council II  and Cardinal Burke has called for a new catechesis  when both of them do not see the factual mistake in the Letter of the Holy Office 1949, upon which so much of Vatican Council II,and their theology, is based.
Vatican Council II does not haev a hermeneutic of continuity only when hypothetical  cases are considered explicit.Subjective cases are considered objective.
If they correct this error and re-read Vatican Council II ,without the premise from 1949 Letter of the Holy Office, the Council does not contradict the traditional teachings of the Church on other religions and Christian communities.
Vatican Council II(Feeneyite) does not contradict the original Syllabus of Errors or the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS).So there is no need for a new Syllabus of Errors.
The new ecumenism is based on Cushingite theology created by the false premise. With the old ecclesiology intact; with Feeneyism, there can only be an old ecclesiology and so only an ecumenism of return.
-Lionel Andrades

JULY 22, 2017

Bishop Schneider will not say that Pope Francis has made an objective mistake and violates the Principle of Non Contradiction


 JULY 22, 2017

Rorate Caeili and Bishop Schneider do not write that Pope Francis made a factual mistake, an objective error in his interpretation of Vatican Council II


ULY 21, 2017

Bishop Athanasius Schneider still incoherent and confused : has repeated last report without addressing previous critical points


JULY 19, 2017

When will Rorate Caeili learn?


JULY 17, 2017

Catholic political parties must teach Catholics the faith which is not being taught by religious due to political pressure


JULY 16, 2017

Ralph Martin and Robert Fastiggi do not deny that Pope Francis interprets Vatican Council II with a false premise and non traditional conclusion


JULY 14, 2017

Ralph Martin, Robert Fastiggi, John Martignoni and Fr. Stefano Visintin osb indicate Pope Francis has violated the Principle of Non Contradiction in his interpretation of Vatican Council II


JULY 13, 2017

Pope Francis violates the Principle of Non Contradiction: chooses irrational interpretation of Vatican Council II which is not the work of the Holy Spirit


JULY 13, 2017

Prof. Robert Fastiggi, Ralph Martin agree that invisible people cannot be visible at the same time : in agreement with Fr. Stefano Visintin's statement


JULY 11, 2017

Fr.Stefano Visintin osb new Rector University of St. Anselm at loggerheads with Cardinal Ladaria: attack on the New Theology with hard facts


JULY 11, 2017

Scientist-Benedictine priest who says the baptism of desire was never an exception to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus is the new Rector at St. Anselm, Rome


JULY 6, 2017

Everything hinges on visible baptism of desire : correct the premise and change the Council


JULY 5, 2017

To accomodate the error of visible baptism of desire Cardinal Ratzinger changed the Profession of Faith, Oath of Fidelity and Canon Law


JULY 3, 2017

The bottom line is that we are all reciting the Nicene Creed but there are two different interpretations


JULY 2, 2017

Cardinal Luiz Ladaria S.j made factual errors in two ITC theological papers which were politically correct


 JULY 1, 2017

Solemn Tridentine Rite Mass tomorrow with manifest sacrilege


JUNE 30, 2017

Tridentine Rite Mass in Rome is a sacrilege : needs to be challenged canonically


JUNE 30, 2017

No priest in Rome will give his telephone number


JUNE 29, 2017

Pamphlet problems : no priest available



No comments: