Experts agree and there is no denial from the Vatican Press Office.Pope Francis interprets Vatican Council II with a false premise and violates the Principle of Non Contradiction. No one disputes this. The basic error is not theology but an empirical observation.It is seeing what is before our eyes,or, rather not seeing.
The pope interprets Vatican Council II with an irrational premise which comes from the Cushing-Feeney dispute.There is an alternative interpretation.The popes does not choose it. It is a Vatican Council II without an irrational premise.I call it Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite).It is not a break with Tradition.
Without the irrational premise 'Rome comes back to the Faith'. The popes and Vatican Council II would be saying all non Catholics are on the path to Hell unless they become members of the Catholic Church.This is what the document says. It is not someones personal view or interpretation.
Magisterial documents interpreted without the irrational premise and inspired by the Holy Spirit indicate all Buddhists, Hindus, Jews, Muslims, atheists and Communists, Pentecostals, evangelicals, Protestants and Orthodox Christians are outside the Church.They are not Catholic.So they are on the way to the fires of Hell.This is the dogmatic teaching in the Catholic Church.It was based on John 3:5, Mark 16:16 etc.
Ralph Martin, Robert Fastiggi, John Martignoni, Fr.Stefano Visintin osb, Fr.George Puthoor, Fr.Nevus Marcello o.p and priests in Rome whom I have contacted, indicate Pope Francis has violated the Principle of Non Contradiction in his interpretation of Vatican Council II.
They all agree that somebody invisible cannot be visible at the same time. They would be supported by all priests most of them ironically would also be violating the Principle of Non Contradiction in their interpretation of the Council.
They all agree that somebody invisible cannot be visible at the same time. They would be supported by all priests most of them ironically would also be violating the Principle of Non Contradiction in their interpretation of the Council.
Here is where they go wrong.Invisible baptism of desire cannot be visible in 2017.There cannot be people whom we personally know who are saved in invincible ignorance of the Gospel through no fault of their own.They would be known only to God if they existed.
Zero cases of something are not exceptions to the dogma EENS says John Martignoni.
He is the Director of the Office of Evangelisation, Archdiocese of Birmingham, Alabama.But for Pope Francis LG 16, LG 14, LG 8, UR 3, NA 2,GS 22 etc are exceptions to Feeneyite EENS.They are not zero cases for the pope.Instead for the pope they are a rupture with Tradition ( EENS, Syllabus of Errors etc).So LG 16, LG 14, LG 8, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc are references to real people , allegedly known people, for them to be exceptions to the 'past ecclesiology'.
He is the Director of the Office of Evangelisation, Archdiocese of Birmingham, Alabama.But for Pope Francis LG 16, LG 14, LG 8, UR 3, NA 2,GS 22 etc are exceptions to Feeneyite EENS.They are not zero cases for the pope.Instead for the pope they are a rupture with Tradition ( EENS, Syllabus of Errors etc).So LG 16, LG 14, LG 8, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc are references to real people , allegedly known people, for them to be exceptions to the 'past ecclesiology'.
Who/what is invisible is assumed by the pope to be visible.People who are saved in Heaven he assumes are also on earth.Then he makes them relevant to the dogma EENS. People who are not objectively seen he infers are like ghosts.This is a violation of Aristotle's Principle of Non Contradiction.
How can someone who is not there before you be presumed to be standing in front of you ? And then based upon this wrong observation a new theology is created ? It says there is known salvation outside the Church?!
The pope has made a factual mistake and his whole interpretation of Vatican Council II is skewered.
It is a fact of life that people in Heaven are generally not observed on earth.It is a fact of life that if someone was saved with the baptism of desire and without the baptism of water, it would not be known to any one on earth.It is a fact of life that someone who died centuries back, may be even a saint,would not be visible and personally known to any one on earth in the present times , to be an exception to Feeneyite EENS.
This is the view of the scientist-Benedictine priest who was a former Dean of Theology at Rome's Benedictine university.Fr.Stefano Visintin osb, the new Rector of the Pontifical University of St. Anselm in Rome, has said that there are no exceptions to the dogma EENS. This is something obvious.No quantum physics here.
Archbishop Thomas E.Gullickson also observes that there are no exceptions to EENS in the present times.There are no objective cases of people saved with the baptism of desire etc.Perhaps the popes will agree with him when this issue is brought to their attention. Presently it could all be only an oversight.
So many Catholics, responsible people, are saying that there are no practical exceptions to Feeneyite EENS.So what I am writing here is not something original and known only to me.It is not a new theology or a new theory. I am not adding any thing new.
Many Catholics know it. Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite) is not ' a development' to EENS( Feeneyite).It means Pope Francis has made an objective error which he needs to correct.-Lionel Andrades
JULY 14, 2017
Ralph Martin, Robert Fastiggi, John Martignoni and Fr. Stefano Visintin osb indicate Pope Francis has violated the Principle of Non Contradiction in his interpretation of Vatican Council II http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2017/07/ralph-martin-robert-fastiggi-john_27.html
Ralph Martin, Robert Fastiggi, John Martignoni and Fr.Stefano Visintin osb agree that somebody invisible cannot be visible at the same time
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2017/07/ralph-martin-robert-fastiggi-john.html
July 13, 2017
Pope Francis violates the Principle of Non Contradiction: chooses irrational interpretation of Vatican Council II which is not the work of the Holy Spirit
eucharistandmission.blogspot.ro/…/pope-francis-vi…
July 12, 2017
Pope's moto proprio suggests there is known salvation and sainthood outside the Catholic Church
eucharistandmission.blogspot.ro/…/popes-moto-prop…
July 13, 2017
Prof. Robert Fastiggi, Ralph Martin agree that invisible people cannot be visible at the same time : in agreement with Fr. Stefano Visintin's statement
eucharistandmission.blogspot.ro/…/prof-robert-fas…
Pope Francis violates the Principle of Non Contradiction: chooses irrational interpretation of Vatican Council II which is not the work of the Holy Spirit
eucharistandmission.blogspot.ro/…/pope-francis-vi…
July 12, 2017
Pope's moto proprio suggests there is known salvation and sainthood outside the Catholic Church
eucharistandmission.blogspot.ro/…/popes-moto-prop…
July 13, 2017
Prof. Robert Fastiggi, Ralph Martin agree that invisible people cannot be visible at the same time : in agreement with Fr. Stefano Visintin's statement
eucharistandmission.blogspot.ro/…/prof-robert-fas…
No comments:
Post a Comment