Monday, July 10, 2017

On the 10th Anniversary of Summorum Pontificum: We thank in particular...- New Catholic, Rorate Caeili (blind leading the blind)

On the 10th Anniversary of Summorum Pontificum: We thank in particular...

from Rorate Caeili
IN PRIMIS... Pope Benedict XVI, Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, Bishop Castro Mayer: long may their memories live!

The beautiful words of that great French hero of the Traditional Mass, Jean Madiran (1920-2013: Rest in peace!), who lived to see the miracle, remembering the names of some who died in the battlefield:

"For thirty seven years, a whole generation of militant Catholics, religious or lay members of the Militant Church (a generation reaching from 7 to 97 years of age) suffered, without giving in, openly defying the arbitrary interdict on the Traditional Mass. We think of our dead: Cardinal Ottaviani, Father Calmel, Father Raymond Dulac, Monsignor Renato Pozzi, Monsignor Lefebvre, Father Guérard. And, among the laymen: Cristina Campo, Luce Quenette, Louis Salleron, Eric de Saventhem. The pontifical goodwill is for them as a light breeze, which sweetly brings peace to their tombs. Wherever they are now, they do not need it anymore. But it is their memory amongst us which is appeased and elevated."

And also: Father GamberMichael DaviesTito Casini, and so many, many others (priests, laymen and laywomen- God knows their names!), each of whom placed his own brick, large or small, in the great dam built for decades against the tumultuous tides of the late twentieth century. Thank you, thank you, thank you dearly! The heat of the battle has caused so much personal attrition, exaggerations, and misunderstandings... Yet, justice cannot be denied: gratitude is owed to those who did not live to see, on this earth, the glorious date of July 7, 2007.

JUNE 11, 2017

There could also have been a Vatican Council II Feeneyite in 1965 if Fr. Nicholas Gruner and Chris Ferrara knew about it.They did not. Neither did Abp. Lefebvre.

JUNE 5, 2017

When Chris Ferrara wrote The Great Facade he did not know Vatican Council II could be interpreted without the irrational premise and the conclusion would be different

FEBRUARY 16, 2014


Did Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre know that implicit desire,invincible ignorance etc were not known to us and irrelevant to the dogma?

JULY 31, 2016

Archbishop Lefebvre's Letter to Confused Catholics indicates he did not know of an alternative interpretation of Vatican Council II which had the hermeneutic of continuity and no ambiguity

Pope Pius XII, Cardinals Ottaviani, Cardinal Francesco Marchetti Selvaggiani and Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre were factually wrong

Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, Michael Davies, Dietrich Von Hildebrand and other traditionalists allowed the Church to continue on a wrong theological way

This group of traditionalists instead of correcting the factual error of 1949 consolidated it and did not expose it

Michael Davis, Romano Amerio, Dietrich von Hildebrand were not aware of the irrational premise : Michael Mat, Chris Ferrara, John Rao, James Bogle, Joseph Shaw agree?

Bishop Bernard Tisseur de Mallerais repeats the error of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre

No response from David Domet, Louie Verrecchio and Boniface when I say that they can interpret Vatican Council II with invisible for us LG 16, LG 14 etc being just invisible.That's all


Prominent lay supporter of the SSPX still does not want to be quoted : Can you see people in Heaven?

Too many people are agreeing with me.They understand Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre made a doctrinal and objective mistake. He contradicted common sense and the Principle of Non Contradiction


JUNE 30, 2017
Tridentine Rite Mass in Rome is a sacrilege : needs to be challenged canonically
JULY 9, 2017
It is a week and no FSSP priest denies what I have written : TLM with manifest mortal sin for politically correct reasons
JULY 3, 2017
Laity could ask the bishop to provide them with FSSP priests who do not make irrational inferences and change the meaning of the Nicene Creed
JULY 3, 2017
FSSP church Santissima Trinita dei Pelligrini : new understanding of Nicene Creed
JULY 10, 2017
Fort Worth, Texas Latin Mass community should appeal to the Marriage Tribunal
JULY 9, 2017
Marriage in Extraordinary or Ordinary form of the Mass in Italy or Germany is being solemnised in mortal sin otherwise no permission would be given by the local bishop
JULY 9, 2017
Engaged- to- be- maried couples should canonically challenge the German bishops and priests to accept Vatican Council ( Feeneyite) in harmony with EENS (Feeneyite)
JULY 8, 2017
Deacon Edward Schaefer unable to say that all Catholics should proclaim that all Jews, Muslims and other non Catholics, with no exceptions in 2017, are oriented to the fires of Hell and this is a magisterial teaching according to Vatican Council II(AG 7, LG 14)
JULY 8, 2017
All Catholics should proclaim that all Jews, Muslims and other non Catholics, with no exceptions in 2017, are oriented to the fires of Hell and this is a magisterial teaching according to Vatican Council II(AG 7, LG 14)
JULY 6, 2017
Everything hinges on visible baptism of desire : correct the premise and change the Council
JULY 5, 2017
That the baptism of desire is invisible and not physically visible is a great secret of Cardinal Ladaria and others at the Vatican.For them this is very important information to hide
JULY 5, 2017
To accomodate the error of visible baptism of desire Cardinal Ratzinger changed the Profession of Faith, Oath of Fidelity and Canon Law
 JULY 5, 2017
When will the SSPX and the St.Benedict Centers simply say that there are no baptism of desire cases in our reality ?
JULY 5, 2017
We can renew our consecration to the Immaculate Heart and also affirm Feeneyite theology and reject the Cushingite one : then see the dramatic difference in Vatican Council II
JULY 5, 2017
SSPX must ask Bishops Conferences in the USA, UK, Italy, etc to affirm Vatican Council II( Feeneyite) or not make the Council an issue for reconciliation
JULY 4, 2017
CDF asks SSPX to interpret Vatican Council II with irrational Cushingism and reject traditional Feeneyism
JULY 4, 2017
FSSP priests need to interpret the Nicene Creed with Feeneyism instead of Cushingism.Bishops must be informed about the error
JULY 3, 2017
The bottom line is that we are all reciting the Nicene Creed but there are two different interpretations
 JUNE 30, 2017
No priest in Rome will give his telephone number
JUNE 29, 2017
Pamphlet problems : no priest available
JUNE 27, 2017
No contradiction or clarification from Fr.Gleize : SSPX in a crisis too
JUNE 26, 2017
Doctrinal talks were conducted with Fr.Gleize on 'the other side'
JUNE 26, 2017
Pope Benedict permitted Fr. Jean Marie Gleize to lead in doctrinal talks since he was a liberal ?
JUNE 25, 2017
Mons. Brunero Gherardini misled the Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary and many traditionalists
JUNE 24, 2017
Official statement from SSPX awaited : Fr.Gleize and other theologians have got it wrong
JUNE 24, 2017
Brother Andre Marie MICM too is teaching error : Bishop Sanborn cannot report at the Chancery office
JUNE 20, 2017
Latin Mass community can canonically challenge catechetical instruction
JUNE 15, 2017
All Board Members of the Collegium Sanctorum Angelorum will have to accept the New Theology at the Latin Mass
JULY 2, 2017
Cardinal Luiz Ladaria S.j made factual errors in two ITC theological papers which were politically correct


DECEMBER 7, 2016

MARCH 7, 2014

Summorum Pontificum : those who do not use an irrational premise in the interpretation of Vatican Council II are called reactionaries

MARCH 7, 2014

Summorum Pontificum does not say if Vatican Council II is to be interpreted with or without the false premise

 AUGUST 25, 2016

The Latin Mass is available in Rome but not the Tridentine Rite Mass.That has been effectivly prohibited by the contemporary magisterium and the political Left.It is not there even at the SSPX chapel

NOVEMBER 19, 2013

Ecclesiology is not dependent on the liturgy

 DECEMBER 3, 2011



APRIL 19, 2017

Pope Benedict XVI could have interpreted Vatican Council II and the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus in March 2016 with Feeneyism instead of Cushingism: he chose heresy and the hermeneutic of rupture

APRIL 19, 2017

Pope Benedict XVI at 90 : theological deception and compromise

No comments: