Sunday, April 15, 2018

Repost : Cristina Siccardi ,Paolo Pasqualucci use the irrational inference in the interpretation of Vatican Council II

JUNE 18, 2014


Cristina Siccardi ,Paolo Pasqualucci use the irrational inference in the interpretation of Vatican Council II

Linverno_della_Chiesa1
Cristina Siccardi has written a review of Il Concilio parallelo by Paolo Pasqualucci.This book is also being sold by the Society of St.Pius X( SSPX).There is a review on Roberto Mattei's Correspondenza Romana. All three of them,Mattei, Siccardi and Pasqualucci have been making the same error of interpreting Vatican Council II with a false inference.
In Christina Siccardi's last book she has quoted Fr. Jean M.Gleize who assumes that NA 2, UR 3 etc refer to salvation VISIBLE on earth.These cases are for him explicit exceptions to extra ecclesiam nulla salus and Tradition. Siccardi repeated the error.
Pasqualucci also infers that there are VISIBLE exceptions to the dogma on exclusive salvation in the Catholic Church.
copertina Concilio parallelo.indd 
I have asked Prof. Roberto Mattei to answer TWO QUESTIONS which will bring out this error for him and others, but he will not respond.Neither will Siccardi respond to e-mail queries.
The error is innocent and has also been made by the SSPX priests and those of  the Franciscans of the Immaculate.
If all salvation mentioned in Vatican Council II is INVISIBLE for us ( and this is rational) then the Council is not a break with the past as is being interpreted presently by Corrispondenza Romano,Rorate Caeili and other traditionalists.
The Franciscans of the Immaculate can affirm Vatican Council II ( without the inference of the VISIBLE dead-saved who are alleged living exceptions to Tradition) along with  the traditional teachings of the Catholic Church on salvation and Christian communities.
It is Fr.Fidenzio Volpi and Sr. Fernanda Barbiero, overseeing the Franciscans of the Immaculate, who must be asked to affirm Vatican Council II without the false inference.
However before this is possible, the traditionalists must admit their error in public.Then they can ask Fr.Volpi and Sr.Barbiero to correct their interpretation of Vatican Council II , which is presently irrational.
-Lionel Andrades

NO ARTICLE ON TRADITIONALIST NEWS AGENCY ENDORSING EXTRA ECCLESIAM NULLA SALUS

http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2014/02/no-article-on-traditionalist-news.html#links


Cristina Siccardi and Prof. Roberto Mattei are making the same error

http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2014/02/cristina-siccardi-like-prof-roberto.html#links

No comments: