Repost : Cardinal Raymond Burke endorses Tradition and Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite).If the SSPX follow him, this is a simple way to canonical recognition
MAY 28, 2018
Cardinal Raymond Burke endorses Tradition and Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite).If the SSPX follow him, this is a simple way to canonical recognition
Cardinal Raymond Burke (center) along with Archbishops Ferrara-Comacchio Luigi Negri and Carlo Vigano at the Rome March for Life, May 19, 2018.LifeSiteNews Cardinal Raymond Burke has called for proclaiming the Social Reign of Christ the King based upon the teachings of the Catholic Church. For him Judaism and Islamism are not paths to salvation and are 'false religions' and the true Church of Christ is not the Protestant or Pentecostal religion which are also false religions which advocate contraception and abortion.1 Yet there is no criticism of Cardinal Burke at the Tablet, National Catholic Reporter or Crux and other pro-Left media.They have just ignored him and not said that Vatican Counci II contradicts him.
Instead it is only a sedevacantist Trad Cat Knight who has wrongly stated on his blog that Vatican Council II contradicts the cardinal when he says non Catholic religions are false, the Catholic Church is the true Church of Christ and it necessary that the Social Reign of Christ the King be lived privately and in public.
APRIL 7, 2018
There is too much of confusion and 'controversy' on this issue for even Edwin Pentin to comment on it.Since if it is said that Vatican Council II says other religions are not paths to salvation, it would be a reference to a hypothetical and speculative statement. Since the ordinary means of salvation is 'faith and baptism' (AG 7) according to Vatican Council II. All those who die in non-Catholic religions are oriented to Hell according to Vatican Council II(AG 7).The ordinary means of salvation is the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus. It is not invincible ignorance or a good conscience(LG 16).So LG 16 refers to a hypothetical statement only.
It is based on the past exclusivist ecclesiology in harmony with Vatican Council II( Feeneyite) that Cardinal Burke has said other religions are not paths to salvation.
So now it cannot be said that LG 8, LG 14, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 are exceptions to the Catholic Church being the one true Church or God(LG 8). Since there cannot be practical exceptions toextra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS).LG 8 etc are not exceptions to EENS.Hypothetical and theoretical cases are not objective examples of salvation in 2018.we cannot meet or see someone saved as suggested hypothetically in Lumen Gentium 8, for example.
Similarly it cannot be said that the Holy Office 1949 was correct and Fr. Leonard Feeney was wrong, since now we know that the baptism of desire, baptism of blood and being saved in invincible ignorance also refer to hypothetical cases, unknown people in the present times, speculation and theoretical possibilities for us humans. If they happened they could only be known to God.There cannot be a concrete case for us human beings on earth.
So how can the National Catholic Reporter, Crux or other liberal media say that Vatican Council II contradicts Cardinal Burke ? They cannot and they have not said so.
We now know that we can interpret Vatican Council II, the Catechisms and EENS withFeeneyism or Cushingism and the conclusion would be a rupture or continuity with Tradition.Cardinal Burke used Feeneyism. So he is affirming Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite) and rejecting Vatican Council II(Cushingite) while also affirming Tradition.He is different from the sedevacantists who affirm Tradition but reject Vatican Council II(Cushingite) and do not know about Vatican Council II(Feeneyite). Similarly he is different from the Society of St. Pius X(SSPX) who affirm Tradition but do not affirm Vatican Council II(Feeneyite)-while they reject Vatican Council II(Cushingite). CATHOLIC CATECHESIS So now in catechesis we can teach that the Catholic Church says all need to be members of this only Church of Christ, for salvation (Ad Gentes 7, Vatican Council II, Cantate Domino Council of Florence 1441, Catechism of the Catholic Church 1257, 845,846 interpreted with Feeneyism) and there are no known exceptions(LG 8 etc are not practical exceptions to EENS or Vatican Council II(Feeneyite). In catechesis the Social Reign of Christ the King, over all political legislation and the non separation of Church and State, needs to be proclaimed and that other religions are false paths to salvation and all their members are oriented to Hell, unless they enter in the Catholic Church where the true Church of Christ subsists(LG 8).
Cardinal Raymond Burke is endorsing Tradition and Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite).If the SSPX follow him, this is a simple way to receive canonical recognition by affirming Vatican Council II and Tradition. Similarly the sedevacantists would know that their interpretation of Vatican Council II (Cushingite instead of Feeneyite) is now obsolete.There is a rational and traditional choice available and Cardinal Raymond Burke has shown the way.-Lionel Andrades 1. https://www.lifesitenews.com/blogs/cardinal-burke-false-religions-that-permit-abortion-should-be-suppressed
Even Vatican II says every one on the face of the earth is called to become a member of the Mystical Body ( the Catholic Church)- Fr.Paul McDonald , Fatima Center