Repost : Someone from the SSPX has to inform the CDF that Vatican Council II cannot be accepted with the false premise : the Council does not contradict the traditional teaching on other religions
JANUARY 7, 2013
Someone from the SSPX has to inform the CDF that Vatican Council II cannot be accepted with the false premise : the Council does not contradict the traditional teaching on other religions
The Society of St.Pius X (SSPX) is not obliged to accept an interpretation of Vatican Council II which assumes the dead saved are visible to us. With this irrational premise Vatican Council II becomes a break with the past.
The dead saved being visible is not part of the hermeneutic of continuity or the deposit of the faith.
It's something irrational that has crawled into the Church since the 1940's and was not corrected by any Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith nor by the SSPX bishops. Neither did Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre correct this error.
Someone has to identify this problem with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Fait,Vatican (CDF) and Ecclesia Dei: so that the next time someone says the SSPX has to accept Vatican Council II, they should specify if they mean with or without the premise of the dead being saved and visible.
Without this premise of the dead saved in invincible ignorant etc who are visible on earth, there is no textual reference to contradict the traditional position of the SSPX on other religions.
When it is understood by the CDF that Vatican Council II does not contradict the teaching onother religions, then the SSPX should be informed .
Meanwhile no SSPX priest at Albano, Italy has been able to cite any text in Vatican Council II which contradicts the SSPX position on other religions.
So the SSPX could accept this interpretation of Vatican Council II, wihout the irrational premise, if the CDF and Ecclesia Dei informs them about it.