Thursday, September 13, 2012

VATICAN COUNCIL II HAS BEEN POLITICISED AND TWO GROUPS ARE REJECTING EACH OTHERS POSITION: VATICAN CURIA AND THE SSPX

At the heart of the differences is the Richard Cushing Error. It determines the hermeneutic of continuity or discontinuity.If there is an ecclesial rupture it will be because the pope does not want to give up the Richard Cushing Error.

The Society of St.Pius X ( SSPX) is faithful to Sacred Tradition inspired by the Holy Spirit. They are rejecting an interpretation of Vatican Council II which is not faithful to Tradition because of the error which emerged from Boston in the 1940's.

There is also political pressure on the Vatican, from forces which are anti-Catholic and who have political power today.They want to prevent a reconciliation and want the Curia to choose heresy and sin.

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vatican (CDF) cannot expect the SSPX, or rational Catholics, to accept that the dead are visible to us and so Lumen Gentium 16 is an exception to the literal interpretation of extra ecclesiam nulla salus..

The CDF cannot suggest that outside the Church there is salvation when we do not know any exception in 2012 or the last 100 years.

How can the CDF believe Vatican Council II says outside the Church there is salvation when no text in the Council makes this claim?

If for political reasons the CDF has to accept that the Council says there is salvation outside the Church, then that is a different thing. It's not part of the Deposit of the Faith.

It  has now been a few years that I have been writing on these same points and no one from the Vatican Curia or elsewhere corrects or contradicts me

The present position of the Vatican Curia seems a political one and they are trying to force it onto the SSPX with threats.

Due to the Cushing heresy, the pope, Vatican Curia, cardinals, bishops and priests, proclaim Jesus without the necessity of being a visible member of the Church for salvation. This heresy is widespread in the Church and they expect the SSPX to accept it.-Lionel Andrades

No comments: