This is rampant with heresy. How dare you even suggest that after 1885
the Ark Of Salvation was in error when clearly pre 1885 they held the
same positions on BOB and BOD etc.
No they did not. Cantate Domino, Council
of Florence 1441 in the text of extra
ecclesiam nulla salus
does not mention BOB,BOD or I.I.
None of the pre-1881 popes and saints who
accepted BOD, BOB or I.I believed that these
cases were concrete and not abstract, known
instead of unknown,visible instead of invisible.
So for them there was no connection between
BOB, BOD and I.I with the dogma.
The connection was made in the Baltimore
Catechism in 1881 when BOD and BOB were
considered baptisms. This was then interpreted
to mean that these cases were explicit and
visible and these were formal baptisms like
the baptism of water. So Catechisms now
refer to three baptisms ( water,blood and desire).
So this was a big change in the teachings of the
Church after 1885.
The Magisterium had changed the traditional
teaching on the exclusive salvation in the
Catholic Church, the only Ark of Salvation
in which all need to be formal members,
all need to have their names on the Parish
Baptism Register to avoid Hell and go to
Heaven.
____________________________________________
AFTER approximately 1960 ( which coincides with the
3rd secret of Fatima) everything changed in sound
catechesis You continue to confuse Church teaching
with Catechesis of Church teaching which has gone
haywire eg: cardinal Cushing, Father Barron, Cardinal
Dolan etc.....who did imply, suggest, teach that non
Catholics can be saved.
You noticed it about the time of Vatican
Council.
However the seeds were planted in
Baltimore in 1885.Perhaps the error
was there even earlier but it was
seen concretly in the Baltimore Catechism.
_________________________________
Lionel come on get real!!!!! We do NOT know AND the
Church does NOT that St. Emerentiana is in Heaven
without having been administered baptism by water.
Good. We agree here.No one could
know at that time or any time that she
was in Heaven without the baptism of water.
________________________________________
BUT the Church does teach that She most certainly
could be in Heaven WITHOUT baptism of water because
God is NOT bound by His sacraments.
The Church, the magisterium teaches
this ? Who was given a special dispensation
or revelation to teach this? What was his
or her name? Who was this person in the
Church who had this Mystical experience
unknown to us and so he or she could
reveal to all that St.Emerentiana is in
Heaven as an exception to EENS?