Thursday, July 7, 2022
Fr.Georges de Laire would be affirming extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS) like the St. Benedict Center, Richmond, New Hampshire in the Diocese of Manchester, NH, USA, if he chose to interpret Magisterial Documents and Doctrines with a Rational Premise. He did not tell this to the media in particular the Catholic Herald, U.K
Fr.Georges de Laire
would be affirming extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS) like the St. Benedict
Center, Richmond, New Hampshire in the Diocese of Manchester, NH, USA, if he
chose to interpret Magisterial Documents and Doctrines with a Rational Premise.
He did not tell this to the media in particular the Catholic Herald, U.K.
He criticized the St.
Benedict Center in the Catholic Herald report. Also when Michael Voris was in
New Hampshire he did not tell him that the diocese affirms the strict
interpretation of EENS like the same Benedict Center, but for the False
Premise.
This would be mean all
the priests and religious communities and lay Catholics would have to consider
Vatican Council II ( rational) as the norm approved by the Congregation for the
Doctrine of the Faith. So all future priests would be Feeneyite on EENS,
Vatican Council II etc.
For the CDF all future
bishops would no more be liberal. There will no more be a
progressivist theology. Since the continued use the False Premise would be
dishonest.
Future priests and
religious sisters, and even the bishop, can only interpret Vatican Council II
rationally and ethically and so there is continuity with the Catholic Church of
the past.
Archbishop Arthur Roche,
like Fr. Georges de Laire is not affirming the dogma EENS in harmony with
Vatican Council II interpreted rationally. He is unethical and also his
interpretation of Traditionis Custode is dishonest.
Archbishop Roche knows
that the Catholic Church is still liberal in England unlike the Catholic Church
in ancient Britain. When the primates choose Vatican Council II (Rational) they
take the Church back to its exclusivist past in theology. There is no other
ethical and rational choice.
Catholic schools must
choose to interpret Magisterial Documents and Doctrines ethically and rationally.
Archbishop Arthur Roche must do it in public and ask Fr. Georges de Laire and
Archbishop Augustine di Noia to do the same.
The 120 members of the
Conservative Party in England must appeal to Cardinal Vince Nicols to return to
the conservative Catholic Church of the past by interpreting Vatican Council II
only with a Rational Premise.
-Lionel Andrades
Posts
