Ignatius Press need to pull down the books of Cardinal Ratzinger.It is unethical to continue to sell them.We now know that the Council can be interpreted with a Rational Premise in harmony with the past exclusivist ecclesiology.

 Ignatius Press is publishing books by authors who interpret Vatican Council II with an Irrational Premise and then pretend there is a break with Tradition, in particular the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.The books of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger are in this category.This is unethical and these books need to be pulled down.

We now know that the Council can be interpreted with a Rational Premise in harmony with the past exclusivist ecclesiology.

Recently on the Catholic World Report it was mentioned that a Jesuit had written another book in which he interpreted Vatican Council II with the Irrational Premise and then made liberal conclusions.Jesuits must be asked to stop writing books on Vatican Council II.

Pope Benedict and Pope Francis have interpreted Vatican Council II irrationally with the Irrational Premise and then with this deception have justified changes in faith and morals.The moral theology being taught at the pontifical universities is based upon the Council interpreted with the Irrational Premise.

The Synods of Pope Francis is also based upon Vatican Council II interpreted irrationally. When asked about the liberalism at  the Synod, Sister Nathalie Becquart. said that it was based upon the ecclesiology of  Vatican Council II.She meant the Council interpreted irrationally and not rationally.The traditionalists and sedevacantists did not comment upon her statement.  Since they too interpret the Council with the Irrational Premise. An exception is Brother Andre Marie micm and the Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary at the St. Benedict Center, Richmond, New Hampshire, in the diocese of Manchester in NH.This traditionalist community interprets the Council with the Rational Premise in harmony with extra ecclesiam nulla salus, according to the missionaries of the 16 th century.-Lionel Andrades

DECEMBER 11, 2022

Mark Brumbley must clarify that he will only accept manuscripts from authors who are rational and ethical in their interpretation of Vatican Council II, the baptism of desire etc. This is being honest, real and Catholic.

https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2022/12/mark-brumbley-must-clarify-that-he-will.html

DECEMBER 11, 2022

Mark Brumbley, President and CEO of Ignatius Press, a conservative and modernist Catholic publishing house, agrees with me when I say that there are no physically visible cases of being saved with the baptism of desire or in invincible ignorance in 2022

https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2022/12/mark-brumbley-president-and-ceo.html

Mark Brumbley must clarify that he will only accept manuscripts from authors who are rational and ethical in their interpretation of Vatican Council II, the baptism of desire etc. This is being honest, real and Catholic.

 

Mark Brumbley, President and CEO of Ignatius Press, a conservative and modernist Catholic publishing house, agrees with me when I say that there are no physically visible cases of being saved with the baptism of desire or in invincible ignorance in 2022.

I had asked him to clarify that he will only accept manuscripts from authors who are rational and ethical in their interpretation of Vatican Council II, the baptism of desire etc. This is being honest, real and Catholic.

How can Ignatius Press publish books by cardinals who suggest that there are physically visible exceptions for Tradition when it is known that there are no such physically visible cases in our reality?

I had said, ‘So there are no physically visible cases of non Catholics saved outside the Church for you. You do not deny it. You agree with me. Yet this is not said by authors at Ignatius including Pope Benedict. He made an objective mistake is books on ecclesiology etc.’

There has no comment or deny by Brumbley on this point.

I had mentioned that ‘when I say that LG 9, 14 and 16 refer to physically invisible cases this would also be your reality. You would agree with me. I am saying the obvious. This is your physical observation too. It is not a theology or only my view. It is also the reality of Fr. Joseph Fessio.

‘It is the common reality of human beings – that the baptism of desire etc refer to invisible people. If someone is saved as such it can be known only to God. We cannot see or meet someone saved outside the Church. This is a given. Yet Ignatius Press authors differ.

‘How can Ignatius Press contradict John Martignoni and suggest that the baptism of desire and being saved in invincible ignorance refer to physically visible cases? This is an irrational premise. It is an objective lie. This cannot be an approved policy for authors.

The apologist at EWTN, John Martignoni, says the baptism of desire and being saved in invincible ignorance are “zero cases” in our reality. Yet, Ignatius Press authors project them as explicit examples of salvation outside the Church and so are exceptions for EENS. 

In communication on Twitter, he does not deny that for him and Fr. Joseph Fessio sj, the founder of Ignatius Press there are no objective cases of non Catholics saved with the baptism of desire( LG 14) or in invincible  ignorance(LG 16).

I had mentioned that Vatican Council II interpreted rationally supports the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus (ENS) as defined by three Church Councils including the Councils of Florence 1441, Cantate Domino, Council of Florence 1441.Vatican Council II is traditional.-Lionel Andrades

DECEMBER 11, 2022

Mark Brumbley, President and CEO of Ignatius Press, a conservative and modernist Catholic publishing house, agrees with me when I say that there are no physically visible cases of being saved with the baptism of desire or in invincible ignorance in 2022

https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2022/12/mark-brumbley-president-and-ceo.html

Mark Brumbley, President and CEO of Ignatius Press, a conservative and modernist Catholic publishing house, agrees with me when I say that there are no physically visible cases of being saved with the baptism of desire or in invincible ignorance in 2022

 Mark Brumbley, President and CEO of Ignatius Press, a conservative and modernist Catholic publishing house, agrees with me when I say that there are no physically visible cases of being saved with the baptism of desire or in invincible ignorance in 2022.

In communication on Twitter, he does not deny that for him and Fr. Joseph Fessio sj, the founder of Ignatius Press there are no objective cases of non Catholics saved with the baptism of desire( LG 14) or in invincible  ignorance(LG 16).

I had mentioned that Vatican Council II interpreted rationally, supports the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus (ENS) as defined by three Church Councils including the Councils of Florence 1441, Cantate Domino, Council of Florence 1441.Vatican Council II is traditional.

I-Lionel Andrades

Mark Brumley is president of Ignatius Press, one of the nation’s largest Catholic publishers and distributors of videos and music.  A former staff apologist with Catholic Answers, he is author of The Seven Deadly Sins of Apologetics from Catholic Answers Press, co-author of A Study Guide for Jesus of Nazareth: Holy Week, and a contributor to The Five Issues That Matter Most.  He is also the executive producer of several documentaries, including The Story of the Nativity, Lost Gospels or False Gospels, and Did Jesus Really Rise from the Dead?.  He is the former director of Communications and of the Office for Social Ministries of the Diocese of San Diego.

Mark Brumley holds a Master’s degree in theology from the University of Dallas and is a regular guest on television and radio, discussing the Catholic faith.  His articles have appeared in such places as Catholic World Report.com, the National Catholic Register, This Rock, The Catholic Answer, and National Review Online. Mark is associate publisher of IgnatiusInsight.com.

More by Mark Brumley

Was Jesus Married? 01/17/2022

Immigration and the Consistent Life Ethic 08/24/2021

Does Catholic Social Teaching Change? 08/07/2020

Are All Elements of Catholic Social Teaching Equally Important? 07/22/2020

Is Catholic Social Teaching Conservative, Liberal, or Moderate? 05/26/2020

Why the Reformation Was Necessary—But Protestantism Was Not 09/01/2017

Don’t Be ‘The Catholic Answer Man’ 05/01/2014

Where Belief and Grace Collide 07/01/2012

Aquinas Proves Atheists Are Closer to God Than They Think 03/01/2009

What Catholics Can Learn from Evangelicals 11/01/2003

Why Miracles Can Happen 12/01/2000

Can Miracles Happen? 11/01/2000

Seven Habits of Effective Apologists 10/01/2000

Let My People Go 07/01/1999

Tradition with a Capital "T" 12/01/1991

Who Can Be Saved? 11/01/1991

The God or a God? 10/01/1991

Is Justification Ongoing? 09/01/1991

Righteousness Done Right 08/01/1991

The Sin of Onan 07/01/1991

What Does the Bible Say About Reincarnation? 01/01/1991

Five Tips on How Not to Handle Fundamentalists 07/01/1990

"Once for All" 06/01/1990

Jehovah’s Witnesses: Masters of Misquotation 04/01/1990

How Many True Gods Are There, Anyway? 02/01/1990

Agreeing to Disagree 01/01/1990

https://www.catholic.com/profile/mark-brumley