Popes from Paul VI to Benedict XVI interpreted Vatican Council II with the hypothetical red passages being practical exceptions to the orthodox blue passages which supported the strict interpretation of the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS). The result was heresy.

The popes from Paul VI to Benedict XVI  interpreted Vatican Council II with the hypothetical red passages being practical exceptions to the orthodox blue passages which supported the strict interpretation of the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS). The result was heresy. They did not announce that Vatican Council II was Feeneyite and could be interpreted with the red passages not contradicting the orthodox blue passages and and the old exclusivist ecclesiology of the Catholic Church.

So in a way Fr. Vaughn Treco was correct to criticize the popes from Paul VI to Benedict XVI who were teaching heresy.

The church St. Bede the Venerable in Minneapolis, USA has been closed and Fr. Vaughn Treco excommunicated by Bishop Steven J. Lopes based upon deception.The bishop says it was because of the alleged  "rejection of the magisterial authority of an Ecumenical Council and a series of popes." 1

When Vatican Council II is interpreted with the red being an exception to the blue then it an objective error. The result is a violation of the Principle of Non Contradiction. This cannot be magisterial. The Holy Spirit cannot teach error. Instead this is human error which is being supported by Bishop Steven J. Lopes.

BISHOP USES FALSE PREMISE AND INFERENCE

It is not being said that the bishop interprets the Council with an irrational premise and inference to create a rupture with Tradition.

It is also not being said that without this irrationality the Council would be in harmony with the past exclusivist ecclesiology and an ecumenism of return but the bishop is not choosing this option.

The bishop forces the irrational interpretation of Vatican Council II upon the parish,who reject it.He now has excommunicated the priest for not accepting it.

IRRATIONAL PHILOSOPHY FROM A BISHOP IS UNETHICAL

This is a secular issue.Irrational philosophy from a bishop is unethical. The deception is now public.It is immoral for a bishop and his Curia to use subterfuge and then force it upon the whole parish.

-Lionel Andrades

1

JULY 9, 2019

Priest hit with Leftist excommunication : Bishop Lopes' interpretation of Vatican Council II is deceptive, unethical and immoral

https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2019/07/priest-hit-with-leftist-excommunication.html