SInce BOD is not an exception to EENS and there are no exceptions to EENS for you are you saying Fr. Leonard Feeney was correct and the Holy Office was wrong and also Vatican Council II does not contradict 16th century EENS?

 

 Comment
Correct. BOD is not an exception to EENS. There are no exceptions to EENS.
You fail to distinguish between absolute and relative necessity, and there is an obvious reason why you do.

Yes they are both hypothetical. We can speculate. In particular cases only God can known.

_______________________________

Correct. BOD is not an exception to EENS. There are no exceptions to EENS. 

Lionel:Agreed.So you are rejecting the New Theology and the New Ecclesiology.

You fail to distinguish between absolute and relative necessity, and there is an obvious reason why you do.

Lionel: Yes they are both hypothetical. We can speculate. In particular cases only God can known.

The distinction between grace and character is fundamental and is made by all the traditional catechisms. Its not an interpretation. 

Lionel: O.K but it is irrelevant to EENS.

SInce BOD is not an exception to EENS and there are no exceptions to EENS for you  are you saying Fr. Leonard Feeney was correct and the Holy Office was wrong and also Vatican Council II does not contradict 16th century EENS?

-Lionel Andrades