An appeal must be made, based on doctrine and theology, for the revocation of the excommunication of Fr. Vaughn Treco.There is confusion among the traditionalist and conservative Catholics, so they cannot support him rationally.

An appeal must be made, based on doctrine and theology, for the revocation of the excommunication of Fr. Vaughn Treco.There is confusion among the traditionalist and conservative Catholics, so they cannot support him rationally.

The traditionalists are not responding to these blog posts since they really are in a soup and there is no Magisterium today to help them out.

I had mentioned that at the Round table Discussion on the Eve of Amazon Synod , Michael Matt will be there who rejects Vatican Council II interpreted with the irrational premise.Taylor Marshall will also be there who, at a meeting of the Fischer More College, accepted Vatican Council II with the false premise as did the FSSP priests and Bishop Olsen.

But neither of the two choose to interpret Vatican Council II without the false premise.It is the same with the other participants at the discussion. It is the same for Fr. Vaughn Treco and his bishop.

So the participants at the Round table discussion or the Remnant's Identity Conference are unable to tell Fr. Treco to interpret Vatican Council II without the false premise and inference and to ask his bishop to do the same.

The traditionalist and conservative Catholics themselves have to interpret Vatican Council II without the false premise.

Once Fr. Treco endorses Vatican Council II without the false premise, he would be affirming exclusive salvation too, as he already does, without rejecting Vatican Council II nor re-interpreting the Council irrationally like Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre.

I mentioned in another blog post that Archbishop Lefebvre did not teach Catholic doctrine at his seminaries.Since for him the baptism of desire, baptism of blood and being saved in invincible ignorance were exceptions to EENS in the Syllabus of Errors. They were also exceptions to EENS in the Athanasius Creed. So he re-interpreted EENS with there being exceptions to the past exclusivist ecclesiology, an ecumenism of return and exclusive salvation as taught in the Catechism of Pope Pius X.

There is no comment from the traditionalist and conservative Catholics since they make the same mistake.

So they need to respond to Fr. Vaughn Treco's excommunication with a rational discussion on doctrine and theology.-Lionel Andrades