Sunday, August 1, 2021

Did Pope Francis issue Traditionis Custode by confusing speculative and practical theology in the interpretation of Vatican Council II ? Yes



That was a good program on outside the Church there is no salvation. I was surprised to see it on the JHW show.It was focused on the book of Eric Sammons so it did not touch the subject of Vatican Council II not being in conflict with outside the Church there is no salvation. 
This really is related to Traditionis Custode.Since Pope Francis only permits the Latin and Novus Ordo Mass for those priests, who interpret Vatican Council II with the irrational premise and so reject Tradition.
This point needs to be brought out in future interviews.Could there be a Vatican Council II which is not a rupture with outside the Church there is no salvation? Is there a Magisterial and non Magisterial interpretation of Vatican Council II, a rational and irrational interpretation of Vatican Council II ?
And if there is such a thing then did Pope Francis use the irrational and non Magisterial interpretation of Vatican Council II ?
If there are two interpretations of Vatican Council II, one with the false premise and the other without it, then there are presently two interpretations of the baptism of desire and invincible ignorance ? This would mean the baptism of desire and invincible ignorance visible would be exceptions to EENS and BOD and I.I while invisible would not be exceptions to EENS.Invisible people cannot be practical exceptions to the Athanasius Creed which says all need Catholic faith for salvation.
So we could still have the strict interpretation of EENS with a rational interpretation of Vatican Council II.This is one of two possibilities.
This would suggest that the interpretation of outside the Church no salvation( extra ecclesiam nulla salus) of John Henry Weston and that of Eric Sammons, could also be with the irrational premise.
Brother Andre Marie MICM at the St. Benedict Center, NH in an interview with Timoth Flanders of the MeaningofCatholic.com (see above ) Youtube shows that he understands the different between speculative and practical theology which is being confused here
This issue of the confusion between speculative and practical theology is there in the Church when Pope Francis cites Vatican Council II. It could also be the interpretation of Vatican Council II by Sammons and Weston.
Did Pope Francis issue Traditionis Custode by confusing speculative and practical theology in the interpretation of Vatican Council II ? Yes.-Lionel Andrades

No comments: