The President of Ignatius, Mark Brumley also publishes books by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger on Vatican Council II, Ecclesiology etc. The same mistake is there in those books too.

 

Ignatius Press publishes the book Salvation by Michael Patrick Barber.It  hides  Catholic doctrine on salvation.For political reasons the author interprets Vatican Council II and the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus with the common Irrational Premise. Then there is a rupture with the traditional strict interpretation of EENS.This is important for his employment. He has been on the faculty of the liberal Augustine Institute, Denver where the President is Tim Price.

If Ignatius Press interpreted Vatican Council II with the Rational Premise then Mark Brumley would have to affirm extra ecclesiam nulla salus like Peter and Michael Dimond at the Most Holy Family Monastery.

The use of the False Premise by Brumley and the present two popes is political. The popes would need to interpret Vatican Council II with the Rational Premise, for them to be Magisterial on the Council.

The Council is Magisterial and in with harmony with the past Magisterium only when it is interpreted with the Rational Premise and Inference.The Conclusion is traditional. The conclusion of Michael Patrick Barber is heretical.It is a rupture with the popes over the centuries.

The dogma says outside the Church there is no  salvation and he believes outside the Church there is salvation. The dogma does not mention any exceptions but for him there are exceptions.The exceptions are created by assuming there are known people in the present times saved outside the Church. So there would be physically visible non Catholics saved outside the Church. They would be visible in Heave or on earth. This is the irrational reasoning.

The present two popes to preserve the Vatican, and also their life, interpret Vatican Council II with the Irrational Premise. This produces a false break with Tradition. 

This is not apostolic.Over the centuries the popes only chose the Rational Premise to interpret the baptism of desire and being saved in invincible ignorance. So there was no confusion with the Creeds, Catechisms and EENS.

Now Barber has chosen the False Premise and produced a break with the apostolic teaching on salvation.He is following the policy of the Augustine Institute.

 The President of Ignatius, Mark Brumley also publishes books by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger on Vatican Council II, Ecclesiology etc. The same mistake is there in those books too.- Lionel Andrades