Dr.Joseph Shaw will have written another politically- correct- with- the- Left book on the Latin Mass like those of Peter Kwasniewski. It will be approved by the liberal English bishops.

 Dr.Joseph Shaw will have written another politically- correct- with- the- Left book on the Latin Mass like those of Peter Kwasniewski. It will be approved by the liberal English bishops.

They interpret Vatican Council II like the Left and so do the Latin Mass Societies and the Federation International Una Voce.

At the Latin Mass they all interpret Vatican Council II irrationally like Pope Francis and the Jewish Left. It is the same at the Novus Ordo Mass.

In this way they are not Feeneyite on extra ecclesiam nulla salus. They can keep publishing books and speaking at conferences.

They do not upset the globalists. They are liberal on Vatican Council II.

Year in and year out they produce the same leftist propaganda on the Council and the Latin Mass.

They know that the common liberalism ends when LG 8, LG 14, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc, are interpreted rationally. But they cannot say this in public. They have families to support and careers to protect.

So Rorate Caeili (web blog) continues with the approved Leftist propaganda. They will not mention that Vatican Council II can be interpreted rationally and then the Council is not a break with Tradition. Instead they will keep posting on the effect of Vatican Council II on society. This is not denied. Since the Council interpreted irrationally, has to produce this result, which is approved by the liberals.

Every year for so many years they keep repeating the same thing. It is as if we do not know it.

Rorate Caeili, Joseph Shaw, Roberto dei Mattei, Peter Kwasniewski are approved by the liberals since they all interpret Vatican Council II irrationally and not rationally. If they interpreted the Council with LG 8, 14 and L6 16 referring to hypothetical cases only, and so not practical exceptions for the dogma EENS, it would be a disaster for the Left. But then Joseph Shaw would be persecuted.

So now these conservative writers, whom the leftist state; the leftist governments calls ’traditionalists’ interpret the Council, at the Latin Mass, like the liberals do at the Novus Ordo Mass. There is no difference between them and the Sant Egidio community in Rome, the St. Anselm University liturgical group and the Bologna School of Alberto Melloni.

However to their favour, many of them reject the result of the Council interpreted with the irrational premise and inference. This is where they differ with the Left.

But they are not really 'traditionalists' since  they do not interpret the Council rationally and so create a continuity with the Magisterium over the centuries at the Latin and Greek Mass.-Lionel Andrades