Bishop Athanasius Schneider does not respond : he still interprets Vatican Council II irrationally as a rupture with Tradition

 

MARCH 12, 2019

Bishop Athanasius Schneider's new website : Can we personally meet and see someone saved with the baptism of desire, baptism of blood or invincible ignorance in 2019 ?

Bishop Athanasius Schneider has a new website which welcomes questions. I sent him this message a minute a ago.

Dear Bishop Athanasius Schneider,
 
Praised be  Jesus and Our Lady.
I am a Catholic lay man in Rome and owner of the blog Eucharist and Mission. I submit the following questions to your Excellency and would like permission to post your answer on my blog. Excuse me for not including a telephone number, since I do not use the telephone. I have not  done so for a few years. I have included my e-mail number and you  are also free to contact me. I have been e-mailing you but have not received a reply.

1.The Catholic Church refers to the baptism of desire,(BOD) baptism of blood (BOB) and being saved in invincible ignorance(I.I), which for me are hypothetical and theoretical cases in 2019. If they happened they would only be known to God. So they are not actual non Catholics who are personally known and who are saved outside the Church.Let me further clarify: I cannot meet or see a person saved with BOD, BOB and I.I in 2019.I cannot say that there were 20 cases of the BOD last year or 25 persons,  the previous year.
Is it the same for you Bishop Schneider? Would your Excellency also say that there are no known cases of BOD, BOB and I.I today and there were none which were physically known and seen for us human beings ?
2.So in 2019  BOD, BOB and I.I cannot be practical exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS) which says all need to be members of the Catholic Church for salvation.
BOD,BOB and I.I never were exceptions to the dogma EENS in 1965 or 1949.
3.   Similarly Lumen Gentium 8 (elements of sanctification and truth), Lumen Gentium 16( invincible ignorance), Lumen Gentium  14 ( the hypothetical case of an unknown catechumen) etc are all hypothetical cases for you ? They are personally invisible people in 2019? So they are not objective exceptions to the dogma EENS, the past exclusivist ecclesiology and an ecumenism of return ?
3.When Unitatitis Redintigratio 3 refers to 'imperfect communion with the Church', this too is a hypothetical case and can never be a known Protestant or Christian saved outside the Church.So UR 3 would not contradict the dogma EENS or an ecumenism of return ?
4.Since LG 8, LG 14, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2,GS 22 etc all refer to hypothetical cases Vatican Council II no where contradicts the Syllabus of Errors on ecumenism and non Christian religions.Non Catholics including Christians need to convert into the Catholic Church for salvation ?(CDF, Notification,Dupuis n.7( 2001).
In Christ
Lionel Andrades

__________________________________________

JUNE 16, 2023

Today is the feast of the Sacred Heart and Cardinal Raymond Leo Burke will offer Holy Mass in Latin while interpreting Vatican Council II, politically, heretically and schismatically. He will support the nontraditional conclusion of Pope Francis and the Left. I have e-mailed him many times. He does not respond.

 

Today is the feast of the Sacred Heart and Cardinal Raymond Leo Burke will offer Holy Mass in Latin while interpreting Vatican Council II, politically, heretically and schismatically. He will support the nontraditional conclusion of Pope Francis and the Left. I have e-mailed him many times. He does not respond. If he interprets Vatican Council II, the Creeds, Catechisms and Councils rationally he could be laicized or expelled. Since then he would be affirming the strict interpretation of the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS) according to the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) and the Council of Florence (1442).These Councils did not mention the baptism of desire as an exception for EENS.

CARDINAL SEMERARO

In the same way Cardinal Semeraro will offer Holy Mass in Italian at Albano, Italy where he will interpret Vatican Council II irrationally, heretically and schismatically. He will accept the nontraditional conclusion which is a rupture with Feeneyite EENS. At Albano, which is the District Headquarters of the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), the priests will do the same at the Latin Mass.

They are all interpreting Vatican Council II irrationally to please the ADL and the rest of the Jewish Left. This is political and not Catholic.

Cardinal Burke and Bishop Athanasius Schneider would respond to an e-mail from John Henry Weston at Left Site News who also interprets Vatican Council II irrationally and does not affirm the Fourth Lateran Council etc. He too is approved by the Left on this issue. -Lionel Andrades