Doctrinal Beliefs of the SBC must be clarified as Cushingite or Feeneyite

Brother Andre Marie MICM, Prior, St.Benedict Center, NH, has posted the Doctrinal Beliefs of the SBC on line, without mentioning that they can be interpreted with Cushingism( hypothetical cases are non hypothetical) or Feeneyism( hypothetical cases are just hypothetical) and the conclusion would be different. The premise determines the conclusion.

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith(CDF) only uses Cushingism.The SSPX and traditionalists too are also Cushingites.

I too would affirm the Doctrinal Beliefs of the SBC as would the SSPX.It is general. However as as a Catholic I would interpret them with Feeneyism.This would be different for Church Militiant TV too which is Cushingite.They make the common Arian-type of heresy in the Church even though they say that they affirm the dogma outside the Church there is no salvation.

It is not enough to affirm extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS).Since the baptism of desire, baptism of blood and invincible ignorance can be exceptions to EENS  which is Cushingism.Or they are not exceptions and this is Feeneyism.

Similarly to recognise being saved in invincible ignorance is not enough.It has to be qualified.

Since invincible ignorance could only be known to God( Feeneyism).For a Cushingite being saved in invincible ignorance outside the Church is also known to us human beings. So it becomes an exception to EENS for them.

Cushingites wrongly imply that the baptism of desire is a known person saved outside the Catholic Church.So it becomes a practical exception to EENS for them.

For the Secretaries of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith(CDF), the Catechism of the Catholic Church 847-848 are exceptions to EENS. They are irrational Cushingites.For me there cannot be exceptions to EENS. CCC 847-848 refers to a hypothetical case only.I cannot imply that there are personally known cases of non Catholics saved outside the Catholic Church in the present times(2019).

Bradley Eli and the Staff at Church Militant TV would agree with the CDF Secretaries, 'the red is an exception to the blue' for them.This thinking creats a rupture with Tradition.It is official though and would be approved by the CDF and the Diocese of Manchester.-Lionel Andrades 

April 18, 2019

Difference between the St. Benedict Center and the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith 

https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2019/04/the-vortex-we-want-to-save-souls_19.html