What is the National Catholic Reporter, Crux and The Tablet going to be without Vatican Council II ? They can no longer quote the Council using a false premise. The Council does not contradict Feeneyite extra ecclesiam nulla salus, an ecumenism of return and the Catechism of Pope Pius X ( 24 Q, 27Q)

Every Catholic must reject a Magisterial document interpreted with a false premise, including Vatican Council II. It is unethical.

Vatican Council II and other Magisterial documents must be interpreted honestly , without the false premise. Then they can be accepted. Since then they are in harmony with Tradition and the past Magisterium of the Catholic Church.

Without the false premise there is no development of doctrine because pre Vatican Council II and post Vatican Council II theology and doctrines are the same.

There is also no liberal-conservative theological division.Since the liberals can no more cite Vatican Council II. They need the false premise for that.

What is the National Catholic Reporter, Crux and The Tablet going to be without Vatican Council II ? They can no longer quote the Council using a false premise. The Council does not contradict Feeneyite extra ecclesiam nulla salus, an ecumenism of return and the Catechism of Pope Pius X ( 24 Q, 27Q). - Lionel Andrades

 FEBRUARY 16, 2021

The books on Vatican Council II reviewed by the National Catholic Reporter (NCR) were all written with a false premise. So their conclusion was false. This is not denied by the NCR correspondents. The books written by Fr. James Wicks s.j , Paul Lakeland and Massimo Faggioli are in this category

 

 

The books on Vatican Council II reviewed by the National Catholic Reporter (NCR) were all written with a false premise.

 

So their conclusion was false. This is not denied by the NCR correspondents.

 

The books written by Fr. Jared Wicks s.j , Paul Lakeland and Massimo Faggioli are in this category. -Lionel Andrades

 https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2021/02/the-books-on-vatican-council-ii.html