Bishop Athanasius Schneider should point out that it is Cardinal Victor Fernandez and Pope Francis who interpret Vatican Council II irrationally and not rationally and so are in schism

 

Bishop Athanasius Schneider is not honest when he says that Archbishop Vigano should not be excommunicated and does not speak the complete truth. Instead he should point out that it is Cardinal Victor Fernandez and Pope Francis who interpret Vatican Council II irrationally and not rationally and so are in schism.He has issued a statement posted on Gloria TV.

 It is Pope Francis who needs to interpret Vatican Council II rationally; this is the only option he has. 

It is those who do not accept Vatican Council II, rational, who are in schism and should be excommunicated, if they do not choose the rational and ethical option.

Bishop Schneider is sadly looking after his own status and does not want to affirm Vatican Council II rational and so affirm the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus, like the St. Benedict Centers, traditionalists in the diocese of Manchester in New Hampshire and Worcester, Mass, USA. He does not want to be called a Feeneyite. So he is interpreting the Council dishonestly like the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vatican.

https://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2024/06/institute-of-christ-kings-superior.html

Similarly Mons. Giles Wach Prior General of the Institute of Christ the King, offers the Latin Mass while interpreting Vatican Council II irrationally. So the Council is a break with Tradition and the ecclesiology of the Roman Missal. He does not announce that the New Missal is flawed since it is based upon Vatican Council II, irrational.

Why must they all expect Archbishop Vigano  to interpret LG 8,14,15,16, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc, irrationally like Pope Francis and Bishop Schneider . Why should Catholics interpret the Council II, irrationally. With the rational interpretation there is no more liberalism in the Church.

If Tom Sawyer s.j editor of the magazine America and John Henry Westen,editor of Life Site News interpret Vatican Council II, rationally, they would be affirming the strict interpretation of the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus and the old theology, whether they like it or not.

Then the liberalism of Cardinal Fernandez will be obsolete. He will be in heresy and schism and will not be able to justify his liberalism with Vatican Council II, rational.

-Lionel Andrades