Fr. Peter Scott, former Rector of the SSPX's Holy Cross Seminary in Australia, answers questions that may be in the minds of many.However he has not responded to this comment on the blog Ecclesia Miltans.Though there is a comment from Fr.Brian Harrison. His view on this subject too, would have been appreciated.
Post a Comment On: Ecclesia Militans
Post a Comment On: Ecclesia Militans
"Fr. Peter Scott Answers"
Catholic Mission said...
Could Rev.Fr.Peter Scott respond to this blog post?
In Christ
Lionel Andrades
Friday, November 4, 2011
DOMINUS IESUS AFFIRMS EXTRA ECCLESIAM NULLA SALUS
Nothing in the document contradicts the dogma
Fr. Peter Scott, former, District Superior, Society of St. Pius X, USA wrote to Bishop Raymond Boland, now Emeritus Bishop of Kansas City, about Dominus Iesus in relation to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus. Bp Boland Letter.qxd www.sspx.org/.../Kansas_City_diocese.pdf
November 04, 2011 11:41 AM
Fr. Brian Harrison said...
How very sad it is that Fr. Scott maligns the new rite of Mass so unjustly!
Of course the rite approved by Paul VI and his successors is still the true propitiatory sacrifice of Calvary, offered in an unbloody manner! It is most certainly not just a Protestant-style "banquet" that offers no sacrifice other than that of human praise and thanksgiving.
If that were true, the new rite of Mass would be inrinsically invalid - something Archbishop Lefebvre himself never claimed.
In every celebration of the Novus Ordo there are at least four affirmations of the true sacrificial character of the Mass, and often five (the fifth one often being found in the "Prayer Over the Gifts" corresponding to the "Secret" in the traditional rite.
May God forgive Fr. Scott for this dreadfully unjust and misleading calumny against the Novus Ordo!
Fr. Brian Harrison, O.S.
St. Louis, Missouri
______________________________________
http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=27605063&postID=4453643920752627089
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment