JANUARY 30, 2018
The way you look at St. Emerentiana decides how you interpret Vatican Council II
https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2018/01/the-way-you-look-at-st-emerentiana.html
St.Emerentiana a possibility - how is she relevant to extra ecclesiam nulla salus?
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2018/01/stemerentiana-possibility-how-is-she.html
______________________________________________
OCTOBER 30, 2013
Elementary My Dear Watson!
Elementary My Dear Watson :The supposed explanation that Sherlock Holmes gave to his assistant, Dr. Watson, when explaining deductions he had made.
Origin
In fact the line doesn't appear in the Conan Doyle books, only later in Sherlock Holmes' films. He does come rather close at a few of points. Holmes says "Elementary" in 'The Crooked Man', and "It was very superficial, my dear Watson, I assure you" in 'The Cardboard Box'. He also says "Exactly, my dear Watson, in three different stories.The phrase was first used by P. G. Wodehouse, in Psmith Journalist, 1915 (1)
_______________________________________
For something to be an exception it has to exist. If something is not there it is not an exception. This is elementary.
If there is a crate of oranges and there is one apple within, the apple in the box is an exception. If it did not exist it would not be an exception. Elementary!
Fr. Jean Marie Gleize of the SSPX in his book on Vatican Council II says there is an exceptional way of salvation. This would imply that there are known exceptions to all needing to convert into the Church for salvation. There are no such known cases! He - does not know anyone saved in imperfect communion with the Church(UR 3). So there are no exceptions! Elementary!
Similarly Archbishop Augustine Di Noia of Ecclesia Deimade an elementary mistake. In an interview with theNational Catholic Register he said that those saved with 'elements of sanctification and truth' (LG 8) are exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.These cases do not exist in our reality.
Likewise Archbishop Gerhard Muller said that being saved in invincible ignorance is an exeption to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus. So for him all do not have to convert into the Church but only those who know. Archbishop Muller does not know who knows and who does not know and will be saved. So why mention it as an exception.It is a possibility yes, but not an exception.
Similarly when the SSPX and SSPX-SO claim there are known exceptions in Vatican Council II to the traditional teaching on other religions, ecumenism and religious liberty they are making an elementary error. There are no such known cases mentioned in Vatican Council II. There are only possibilities.
Bishop Athanasius Schneider and Michael Voris also made a fundamental error when they claimed Vatican Council II is ambigous. Yes it would be ambigous if you asumed we could see the dead saved in invincible ignorance etc.Salvation in Heaven in 2013 is not visible to us on earth. Elementary My Dear Watson.
Invincible ignorance and the baptism of desire are not known cases.So they are not exceptions to the literal interpretation of the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus as interpreted by Tradition and Fr.Leonard Feeney.
Elementary My Dear Watson.
-Lionel Andrades
1.
http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/elementary-my-dear-watson.html
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2012/11/archbishop-thomas-egullickson-says.html#links
Implicit intention, invincible ignorance and a good conscience (LG 16) in Vatican Council II do not contradict extra ecclesiam nulla salus –John Martigioni
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2012/11/archbishop-thomas-egullickson-says.html#links
____________________________
OCTOBER 11, 2018
Repost : St.Emerentiana is not an exception to extra ecclesiam nulla salus, the Feeneyite version, in 2015
https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2018/10/repost-stemerentiana-is-not-exception.html
JANUARY 24, 2018
Ann Barnhardt still uses Cushingite theology like the other traditionalists
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2018/01/ann-barnhardt-still-uses-cushingite.html
____________________________
What is Feeneyism? (Graphics)
JANUARY 27, 2018
What is Cushingism ?(Graphics)
- Grafics (baptism of desire (1)
- Grafics (Exceptions) (1)
- Grafics (Fr.Leonard Feeney) (1)
- Gran Maestro della Gran Loggia Regolare d’Italia (GLRI) (1)
- Grapchics ( Time to Resign) (1)
- Graphics (98)
- Graphics ( Ad Gentes 7 (2)
- Graphics ( Back to the Basics) (2)
- Graphics ( Canon Law) (1)
- Graphics ( Hungary) (2)
- Graphics ( Joint Declaration with Lutherans on Justification) (1)
- Graphics ( Lay Movements) (1)
- Graphics ( Not me ) (1)
- Graphics ( Official interpretation of the Council without the error) (2)
- Graphics ( Redemptoris Missio) (1)
- Graphics (Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre) (2)
- Graphics (Baptism of Desire) (1)
- Graphics (Bp.Barron) (1)
- Graphics (Bp.Kevin Rhoades) (7)
- Graphics (Cushingism) (2)
- Graphics (Ecumenism) (2)
- Graphics (German Bishops) (4)
- Graphics (Hungary) (1)
- Graphics (Lay Movements) (2)
- Graphics (LOHO) (3)
- Graphics (Mission) (2)
- Graphics (Mixed) (2)
- Graphics (Not me) (1)
- Graphics (Pope Paul VI) (2)
- Graphics (Primer on Feeneyism and Cushingism ) (1)
- Graphics (Principle of Non Contradiction Violated) (1)
- Graphics (Professors ask seminarians/students to choose Feeneyism ) (1)
- Graphics (Sedevacantism) (2)
- Graphics (Social Reign of Christ the King) (4)
- Graphics (SSPX) (2)
- Graphics (Traditionalists) (2)
- Graphics (Vatican Council II and Mission) (1)
- Graphics Gospel of St.John (4)
- Graphics-Decide (6)
- Graphics-VC 2 says outside the Church no salvation) (3)
- Graphics( Archbishop Thomas E Gullickson) (1)
- Graphics( Archdiocese of Palermo) (1)
- Graphics( CDF and Traditonalists on interpretation of Vatican Council II) (1)
- Graphics( Hell) (1)
- Graphics( They Did Not Know) (1)
- Graphics( VC2 and volcanic images)(1)
- Graphics(CDF) (1)
- Graphics(Fr.Leonard Feeney) (1)
- Graphics(LOHO) (2)
- Graphics(Mission) (1)
- Graphics(Misson) (2)
- Graphics(Mixed) (14)
- Graphics(Pope Paul VI) (1)
- Graphics(St.Emerentiana) (1)