Wednesday, November 18, 2020

Bishop Donald Sanborn and Prof. Robert Fastiggi will not answer THREE QUESTIONS.In their debate they both use the false premise to interpret Vatican Council II


Bishop Donald Sanborn and Prof. Robert Fastiggi will not answer THREE QUESTIONS.In their debate they both use the false premise to interpret Vatican Council II
Without the false premise Bishop Sanborn could   re-interpret Vatican Council II  rationally and so does not have to reject the Council since it will not oppose Tradition. Similarly Prof.  Fastiggi could re -interpret the Council rationally emerge a conservative with no option for his present liberalism. -Lionel Andrades



THREE QUESTIONS

 



1.How do you interpret Vatican Council II - with LG 8,LG 14, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc referring to explicit or implicit cases, objective or subjective cases, visible or invisible people in the present times ?

2.If LG 8,LG 14, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc in Vatican Council II are invisible, subjective and implicit,  then LG 8 etc, in Vatican Council II, do not contradict the Athanasius Creed, the Syllabus of Errors and exclusive salvation in the Catholic Church?

3.Do you support Tradition(exclusive salvation) and a rational interpretation of Vatican Council II ? -Lionel Andrades


________________________________

Peter Kwasniewski like the present two popes, interprets the Creeds with the false premise, rejects exclusive salvation in the Catholic Church and with this first class heresy and public schism,goes up to receive the Eucharist kneeling and on the tongue at Mass in Latin, with the priest not facing the congregation, then he considers the liturgy licit, fitting, authentic and valid

Peter Kwasniewski like the present two popes, interprets the Creeds with the false premise, rejects exclusive salvation in the Catholic Church and with this first class heresy and public schism,goes up to receive the Eucharist kneeling and on the tongue at Mass in Latin, with the priest not facing the congregation, then he considers the liturgy licit, fitting, authentic and valid. -Lionel Andrades

NOVEMBER 17, 2020

Peter Kwasniewski goes for a Latin Mass (not TLM) permitted by the Cushingite Vatican, where the priests and congregation affirm the New Theology, New Ecclesiology, New Ecumenism etc all created with a false premise

https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2020/11/peter-kwasniewski-goes-for-latin-mass.html

 NOVEMBER 17, 2020

Peter Kwasniewski attends a valid, licit, fitting and authentic Latin Mass in which the priest is forced to affirm Cushingite doctrines, which are heretical and schismatic. They are officially approved by the present two popes, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and Cardinal Robert Sarah's Congregation for Divine Worship, Vatican

https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2020/11/peter-kwasniewski-attends-valid-licit.html


NOVEMBER 15, 2020

If the SSPX would announce that they accept Vatican Council II interpreted with the false premise their Mass would be doctrinally licit for the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Congregation for Divine Liturgy, Pope Benedict and Pope Francis, cardinals and bishops and Peter Kwasniewski


NOVEMBER 15, 2020

The Mass of Kiko Arguello's New Catechumenal Way is licit since the priest is Christocentric and not Ecclesiocentric like at the Traditional Latin Mass of the 16th century. The Mass of the Way is licit for the Vatican and it would also be licit and authentic for Peter Kwasniewski


NOVEMBER 15, 2020

Michael Matt attends Mass in Latin at a church in the USA where the priest accepts Vatican Council II interpreted with a false premise and he also re-interprets the Creeds and Catechisms non traditionally. This is approved by the USCCB.They consider this Mass licit and without impediments even though the theology is heretical and schismatic and a rupture with the ecclesiology of the Traditional Latin Mass of the missionaries in the 16th century and also the Byzantine Greek Mass of the third century. For Peter Kwasniewski this is authentic and fitting liturgy

NOVEMBER 15, 2020

The Rome Vicariate only grants incardination to liberal priests who reject the dogma EENS and interpret Vatican Council II with a false premise and so change the meaning of the Nicene Creed. With the false premise they are also rejecting the the Athanasius Creed.They interpret all the Catechisms with the false premise creating heresy and schism. The Mass of these priests is considered licit. They would meet Peter Kwasniewski's critieria for explaining the Liturgy.Priests who offer the Latin Mass are also granted incardination when they meet the heretical and schismatic doctrinal requirements


 NOVEMBER 15, 2020

An FSSP priest could offer the Novus Ordo Mass in Italian and interpret the Creeds, Catechisms and Vatican Council II without the false premise and so there would not be a change in the First Commandment while another FSSP priest could offer the Latin Mass while intepreting the Creeds, Catechisms and Vatican Council II with the false premise creating first class heresy and an impediment to offering Holy Mass.This Latin Mass would still be valid, licit, fitting and authentic for Peter Kwasniewski


NOVEMBER 15, 2020

When the FSSP priest rejects the Athanasiius Creed and changes the understanding of the Nicene and Apostles Creed it is an impediment to offering Holy Mass, for example, at the church Santissima Trinita dei Pelligrini, Rome. Yet for Peter Kwasniewski this Mass in Latin could be valid, licit , fitting and authentic

 NOVEMBER 15, 2020

Peter Kwasniewski considers Holy Mass valid, licit , fitting and authentic when the priest and congregation change the traditional interpretation of the Creeds , Catechisms and interpret also Vatican Council II with a false premise.This break with Tradition and the resulting heresy and schism officially approved by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and the popes, is valid, licit , fitting and authentic for him.


NOVEMBER 15, 2020

Peter Kwasniewski even after being informed will not interpret Vatican Council II without the false premise. LG 16 refers to invisible or visible cases in 2020 for him ? No answer. LG 8 in Vatican Council II refers to an objective person or a hypothetical case in 2020 for him ? No answer. Could he interpret theoretical cases of UR 3 as not contradicting the old ecumenism of return ? No answer. He does not want to answer



______________________



https://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2020/11/the-four-qualities-of-liturgy-validity.html

When the Catechism of the Catholic Church (1257-The Necessity of Baptism ) states 'God is not limited to the Sacraments' this is heresy.Of course God chooses to limit salvation to the Sacraments according to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus ( Council of Florence 1441) and the Athanasius Creed ( all need to be Catholic for salvation)

 When the Catechism of the Catholic Church (1257-The Necessity of Baptism ) states 'God is not limited to the Sacraments' this is heresy.Of course God chooses to limit salvation  to the Sacraments according to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus ( Council of Florence 1441) and the Athanasius Creed ( all need to be Catholic for salvation).

God is limited to the Sacraments according to the Catechism of Pope Pius X ( 24 Q,27Q).Theoretical and speculative cases of the baptism of desire,invincible ignorance etc are not practical exceptions.

God has chosen to limit salvation to Catholic faith and the baptism of water(Vatican Council II) and CCC 1257 says the Church knows of no means to eternal beatitude other that the baptism of water.-Lionel Andrades

Priest who ministers at Medjugorje shares Mary’s message of love

 

Priest who ministers at Medjugorje shares Mary’s message of love

Dominican Father Leon Pereira, chaplain to the English-speaking pilgrims at Medjugorje poses on March 7 with Father Rick Nagel, pastor of St. John the Evangelist Parish in Indianapolis. (Submitted photo by Jennifer Lindberg)

Dominican Father Leon Pereira, chaplain to the English-speaking pilgrims at Medjugorje poses on March 7 with Father Rick Nagel, pastor of St. John the Evangelist Parish in Indianapolis. (Submitted photo by Jennifer Lindberg)

By Jennifer Lindberg (Special to The Criterion)

He asked the Blessed Mother to never allow him to lapse from his Catholic faith again. She took him at his word, leading him to change his white coat of an emergency room doctor for the white habit of a Dominican priest.

Dominican Father Leon Pereira spoke at St. John the Evangelist Parish in Indianapolis on March 7 about the love the Virgin Mary has for all her children, and about how the “Five Stones and Five Messages of Our Lady” helps one in their spiritual life.

Father Leon was only a 20-year‑old army private when he heard the Virgin Mary speak to him. Growing up in Singapore with his Indian parents, he was required to do a mandatory stint in the army in Singapore, which led to a spinal injury. While recuperating, he traveled to Medjugorje.

“ ‘I am your mother, the Mother of God,’ ” Father Leon said he heard while in Medjugorje. “ ‘Tell everyone you meet that I am their mother, and that I love them.’

“When she said this,” Father Leon said, “you felt immediately how she loved you. Watching her was to be loved by her. She made me feel how she loves everyone like you are her only child.”

Father Leon, the official chaplain for all English-speaking pilgrims in Medjugorje, says he owes his priesthood to Medjugorje, a village in Bosnia where many believe that the Virgin Mary has been appearing for the past 38 years. While the Church has not declared the apparitions to be of supernatural origin, a Vatican commission voted in 2017 in favor of recognizing the first seven apparitions that occurred in 1981.

That same year, Pope Francis appointed Archbishop Henryk Hoser of Poland as a papal envoy to Medjugorje. In December 2017, Archbishop Hoser declared that parishes and diocese were permitted to lead official pilgrimages to the site.

Father Rick Nagel, pastor of St. John the Evangelist Parish, said Father Leon’s talk was to “provide hope and light, especially in our time for our Church.”

Father Leon was traveling on a six‑state tour with the message that he said the Virgin Mary asked him to convey. Sharing his experience, he described seeing the Virgin Mary on Cross Mountain in Medjugorje.

“She looks very young,” he said. “Small, petite. She wore a veil on her head that hung straight down. It did not droop over her shoulders. It was a very simple dress; her hand had the palms facing upward like the Immaculate Conception pose.”

The priest said everything about her was “golden and gleaming.” It wasn’t until he was in St. James Church in Medjugorje that he said he heard the Virgin Mary speak to him and give him instructions to tell everyone of her love.

While he tells this story as Our Lady asked, Father Leon wants to deflect attention from himself.

“What I really want to talk about is the context of the Five Stones,” he said, referring to five means of conversion. “There is nothing special about me.”

It took many years for Father Leon to fulfill this mission or tell anyone of his experience. It was so overwhelming, he said, that he hesitated to even mention it. In England, while studying to be a doctor, people would make fun of Medjugorje and he would laugh with them, he said. But that encounter in Medjugorje never left him, making everything else he wanted to do with his life seem insignificant in comparison.

Leaving the medical world, he was ordained as a Dominican friar of the order’s English province. He served as prior and parish priest of Holy Cross Priory in Leicester, England, and as subprior of St. Dominic’s Priory in London. He also taught moral theology in England to seminarians at Blackfriars at Oxford University and at Oscott College in Birmingham. In 2015, Father Leon was appointed the chaplain for English‑speaking pilgrims in Medjugorje.

In Medjugorje, he has lived the five stones way that he preaches about. The five stones are named after the ones David picked up to slay Goliath in the Old Testament. These stones are “weapons Our Lady gives us to aid in our conversion,” said Father Leon.

Those stones are: praying with the heart, holy Mass, reading the holy Bible, fasting and confession.

Father Leon said we often pray for what we think we should—such as for world peace—but we often don’t tell God what is in our hearts and what we really need. He said praying from the heart also involves praying the rosary every day, noting that in Medjugorje, Our Lady asked for the joyful, sorrowful and glorious mysteries to be prayed every day.

“This is only 45 minutes out of your day,” he said.

“The rosary is a time machine,” Father Leon said. “When you pray the third mystery of the joyful mystery, you are getting the power of that first Christmas that comes to you now as you pray the third joyful mystery. Exorcists will tell you that the demons hate the rosary. It weakens the demon’s power on this Earth.”

As for Mass, he told the story of a priest friend martyred in Iraq whose cause for canonization is before Pope Francis. His friend was told not to celebrate Mass or he would be killed.

“He told them, ‘Without the Mass, we cannot live,’ and they shot and killed him,” Father Leon said. “We need to understand the importance of the Mass.”

The Bible is to be in a place where you will read it, said Father Leon.

“We need to know the Bible better because it is our book,” he said. “If you read it every morning, you are stronger.”

Father Leon also encouraged his listeners to follow the ancient Christian practice of fasting on Wednesday and Friday, which he said Mary likely would have done.

Lastly, he said our Lady asked for more frequent confession, at least once a month.

“She said whole regions would be converted if we went to confession once a month,” he said.

“Do you just wash your clothes on Easter and Christmas?” he asked. “So why not go to confession more regularly?”

Father Leon’s role as chaplain requires him to look after every English-speaking pilgrim to make sure they have Mass and confession properly. He reports to the Franciscans who oversee the parish church of St. James and to Archbishop Hoser, who now serves as apostolic visitor to St. James Parish in Medjugorje.

Father Leon said that living in Medjugorje and ministering to the pilgrim’s needs has taught him a deep truth: “To trust in divine Providence and in Our Lady and her care of me.”
 

(Jennifer Lindberg is a freelance writer and a member of St. Joseph Parish in Shelbyville.) 

The First Commandment in the Catechism of the Catholic Church does not say that there is true worship in only the Catholic Church.

 The First Commandment in the Catechism of the Catholic Church does not say that there is true worship in only the Catholic Church.

Cardinal Ratzinger has often said that Jews do not need to convert into the Catholic Church for salvation contradicting Jesus in the Gospel of John. 

If asked he would say that Vatican Council II says outside the Church there is salvation.He means, that for him, the Council says this when it is interpreted with a false premise. 
Without the false premise he could not cite Vatican Council II to support his liberalism.

Similarly CCC 846 (Outside the Church No Salvation) does not state  that every one needs to enter the Catholic Church for salvation. Since with the false premise Lumen Gentium 16 ( invincible ignorance) etc are made practical exceptions to EENS etc.

Then CCC 1257 ( The Necessity of Baptism) states the Church knows of no means to eternal beatitude other than the baptism of water but CCC 1257 contradicts itself  and says'God is not limited to the Sacraments'.

This is heresy. CCC 1257 is a rupture with the dogma EENS and the Athanasius Creed.

 He interprets the baptism of desire,baptism of blood and invincible ignorance with a false premise.So they are made exceptions to exclusive salvation( Catechism of Pope Pius X ,24Q,27Q).

Pope Benedict and Archbishop Guido Pozzo wanted the Society of St.Pius X to accept all this doctrinal confusion for canonical recognition. -Lionel Andrades

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vatican is a political office in harmony with the Left, so it is above reproach like the present pope. Church and the Leftist State are not separated today. In the past the CDF was a political office, a part of the papal states, in harmony with the popes and orthodox Catholic faith and morals. Now it's moral theology is based upon subjectivism and its salvation theology is infected with Cushingism.

 The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vatican is a political office in harmony with the Left, so it is above reproach like the present pope. Church and the Leftist State are not separated today.

In the past the CDF was a political office, a part of the papal states, in harmony with the popes and orthodox Catholic faith and morals.

Now it's moral theology is based upon subjectivism and its salvation theology is infected with Cushingism. -Lionel Andrades

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vatican can simply announce that there are no practical exceptions mentioned in Vatican Council II, to EENS and the Athanasius Creed. In this way the common error in the Church will be corrected over time

 The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Vatican can simply announce that there are no practical exceptions mentioned in Vatican Council II, to EENS and the Athanasius Creed. In this way the common error in the Church will be corrected over time. -Lionel Andrades

Cardinal Ratzinger let down the Church when his Catechism of the Catholic Church did not affirm traditional exclusive salvation CCC 2095 etc(First Commandment), CCC 846 (Outside the Church No Salvation) and CCC 1257 (The Necessity of Baptism). When he states 'God is not limited to the Sacraments'(CCC 1257) it is the heresy of the Letter of the Holy Office 1949.

Cardinal Ratzinger let down the Church when his Catechism of the Catholic Church did not affirm traditional exclusive salvation CCC 2095 etc(First Commandment), CCC 846 (Outside the Church No Salvation) and CCC 1257 (The Necessity of Baptism). When he states 'God is not limited to the Sacraments'(CCC 1257) it is the heresy of the Letter of the Holy Office 1949.-Lionel Andrades

Gesù liberaci dalle varie preoccupazioni...