Friday, July 6, 2012

IS THE HOLY SPIRIT SAYING LIKE ARCHBISHOP AUGUSTINE DI NOIA THAT LG 8, LG 16 ARE EXPLICITLY KNOWN AND ARE EXCEPTIONS TO THE DOGMA?


There are two interpretations of Vatican Council II and they  depend upon LG 8 and LG 16 being explicit or implicit.

SSPX should ask DI Noia to affirm Vatican Council II and avoid a schism.

The Left could be asking the pope to excommunicate the Society of St.Pius X and the SSPX could prevent this by acknowledging that there can be an interpretation of Vatican Council II with Lumen Gentium 8 and Lumen Gentium 16 implicit.

The Holy Spirit cannot make an error. The Holy Spirit cannot teach irrationality, like an explicitly known to us LG 8, LG 16 which contradicts AG 7 and the dogma on exclusive salvation.

Di Noia, according to the leftist La Stampa wants the SSPX to accept the demands of the Jewish Left.There are  two in particular.

1) Jews do not have to convert in the present times.

2) Vatican Council II contradicts the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus and they want this interpretation accepted.

The SSPX can respond :

1) The SSPX accepts implicit LG 8 and LG 16 which is in accord with Tradition and so Vatican Council II does not contradict the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.

In this way the SSPX affirms Vatican Council II and also the Biblical teaching that Jews need to convert (AG 7).

Bishop Bernard Fellay has signed the Doctrinal Preamble accepting Vatican Council II as a continuity with the past. This interpretation does not have the hermeneutuc of rupture.Vatican Council II according to Di Noia, Ladaria and Koch is a break with Tradition.

So as a follow up to the document signed it needs to be affirmed that LG 8 and LG 16 are always implicit. So there is nothing in Vatican Council II which contradicts the literal interpretation of the text of Cantata Domino, Council of Florence 1441.

As a Catholic I affirm Vatican Council II in accord with the dogma the SSPX could do the same. Ad Gentes 7 supports the dogma and LG 8 and LG 16 are not exceptions.

This interpretation is in agreement with the Holy Spirit’s teaching the Church throughout the centuries that there is exclusive salvation in only the Catholic Church.-Lionel Andrades

Archbishop Augustine Di Noia says the Holy Spirit preserves the Church from error including the interpretation of Vatican Council II- we now know there are two interpretations of Vatican Council II, which one is guided by the Holy Spirit ?

WHAT WAS THE THEOLOGICAL LIST GIVEN TO THE SSPX AT THE LAST CDF MEETING ?