The Society of St.Pius X (SSPX) bishops and priests indicate that there are literal exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS) when they do not know of any literal cases. So for them there are also literal exceptions to the Athanasius Creed ( outside the Church no salvation) and the Syllabus of Errors of Pope Pius IX, when they do not know any real case in 2020.They will not affirm the strict Feeneyite interpretation of EENS, since the baptism of desire(BOD), baptism of blood(BOB) and invincible ignorance(I.I) are exceptions for them.So they have also changed the interpretation of the Nicene Creed and the Catechism of Pope Pius X by assuming invisible cases (BOD, BOB and I.I ) are visible in order to be exceptions to EENS.This is irrational and not Catholic philosophical reasoning.
Archbishop Lefebvre, Michael Davies, Roberto dei Mattei,Chris Ferrara, Fr. Nicholas Gruner,Michael Matt and the Hildebrands made a factual mistake. It is also repeated by Don Neto Ray of Gloria TV.
Archbishop Lefebvre, Michael Davies, Roberto dei Mattei,Chris Ferrara, Fr. Nicholas Gruner,Michael Matt and the Hildebrands made a factual mistake. It is also repeated by Don Neto Ray of Gloria TV.
It is a fact of life that there are no objective exceptions to EENS, the Creeds, Catechisms and Vatican Council II(AG 7).
Yet with all this doctrinal confusion and heresy the SSPX refer to themselves as traditionalists who follow Tradition. They also act as if their theology and ecclesiology today is the same as the missionaries in the 16th century when they offered the Traditional Latin Mass.
Fr. John Zuhsldorf interprets Vatican Council II, EENS, the Catechisms and Creeds with Cushingism.So with the new ecclesiology he offers Holy Mass in Latin.
UNITE THE CLANS WITH NEW THEOLOGY
They want to 'unite the clans' with the false new theology of the liberals, the Left and the present two popes who are in a rupture with Tradition.Ths is a rupture which they can avoid,if they are willing to be politically incorrect.
The traditionalists even after being informed, for political reasons will not affim EENS without exceptions. So they offer Holy Office in Latin with scandal and heresy. This is a sacrilege.
A professor of philosophy in the USA who attends the Latin Mass agrees that this is heresy and a sacrilege for those who interpret Magisterial documents with Cushingism.It is a mortal sin of faith.
The SSPX must stop interpreting LG 8, LG 16 etc as a rupture with EENS and admit that Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre made a mistake. They must also call out the same mistake in the present two popes and the German bishops.
Feeneyite traditionalists like Brother Andre Marie MICM, avoid this heresy and sacrilege.There are no literal exceptions to EENS for the Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary at the St. Benedict Center, New Hampshire.There are none mentioned in Vatican Council II. They attend Holy Mass in Latin with the old ecclesiology in their mind and do not deny it in public.-Lionel Andrades
__________________________
__________________________
-Lionel Andrades
Posts
