Thursday, December 27, 2012

THE SSPX CANNOT CITE ANY TEXT IN VATICAN COUNCIL II WHICH CONTRADICTS THE TRADITIONAL TEACHING ON OTHER RELIGIONS- THEY HAVE TO USE THE DEAD MAN WALKING THEORY

SSPX CAN PR0VIDE NO REFERENCE IN VATICAN COUNCIL II WHICH CONTRADICTS THE TRADITIONAL UNDERSTANDING OF OUTSIDE THE CHURCH THERE IS NO SALVATION

On the U.S website of the SSPX a comparision is made between Tradition and Vatican Council II. The SSPX are unable to show in this comparision where does Vatican Council II contradict the Catholic Church' traditional teaching on other religions or the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.

The SSPX websites states:

Contrary magisterial teaching

Finally, some incoherence is readily perceived if one peruses the Council texts and compares them with Church Tradition. Is it impertinent to wonder whether we can speak of continuity in the magisterium when one accepts the following propositions side by side?

Tradition                                                  
The Church of Jesus Christ is only the Catholic Church

Vatican II

and is not only the Catholic Church.

Tradition  
The truth in religious matters is the Catholic faith alone

Vatican II

and is not the Catholic faith alone.

Tradition   
The dissident churches are not proper churches,

Vatican II

and the dissident churches are, although in a way distinct from the Catholic, true churches.

Tradition  Souls can be sanctified within the dissident communities despite of them,

Vatican II

and souls can be sanctified in them and thanks to them.

Tradition

Man has in principle no right to religious freedom to propagate error in countries (although this could be tolerated),

Vatican II

and Man has in principle a right to religious freedom and to non-Catholic propaganda.

Tradition

Human nature is not the foundation of any right to religious freedom and

Vatican II

human nature is the foundation of the right to religious freedom.

Tradition

Outside the Church there is no salvation,

Vatican II

and outside Vatican II there is no traditionalist salvation. (1)

-Lionel Andrades

1
http://www.sspx.org/sspx_and_rome/is_the_sspx_heretical_4_12-19-2012.htm    

SSPX CLAIMS TRADITION TAUGHT THAT OUTSIDE THE CHURCH THERE IS NO SALVATION BUT VATICAN COUNCIL II DOES NOT TEACH THIS
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2012/12/sspx-claims-tradition-taught-that.html#links

No comments: