Bishop Frederick Henry wants the St.Dennis Catholic Church,Calgary to accept the dead man walking theory in Vatican Council II, to get canonical status.The bishop of Calgary like the Vatican Curia cardinals and bishops have canonical status since they affirm Vatican Council II with the dead man walking theory and so the Council emerges modernist.They claim that these cases of the dead visible and saved are exceptions to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus. Of course if there were none of these exceptions then Vatican Council II would not contradict the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus and the Council would not be modernist and heretical.
The Society of St.Pius X (SSPX) members at the St.Dennis Catholic Church in Calgary , may, like other SSPX members, affirm that non Catholic religions are not paths to salvation. However like SSPX members they may also say that the dead saved in invincible ignorance are exceptions to the dogma on salvation.So for them too like Bishop Frederick Henry, the Catechism and Vatican Council II contradicts extra ecclesiam nulla salus. On this issue the progressives and traditionalists are united.United in irrationality.
So expectedly the St.Dennis Catholic Church rejects Vatican Council II, which contains the false premise of being able to see the dead, and the SSPX members assume, that the Council contradicts their traditional position on other religions.
They could, if they want, based on reason, show the bishop of Calgary that there could be two interpretations to the Catechism and Vatican Council II - a rational and an irrational one.
Even if they are not going to accept Vatican Council II they can still inform Bishop Frederick Henry that we cannot see the dead so the Catechism and Vatican Council II cannot be interpreted with this false premise.They could still inform the bishop that there is nothing rational in the Council which contradicts the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus.
How can Catholics attend Mass when the bishop does not accept extra ecclesiam nulla salus, when he denies the dogma with irrationality ? How can he say that he accepts Vatican Council II and the Catechism in its totality and then assume that the dead who are saved are visible to all in 2013? This is his interpretation of the Council and Catechism?.-Lionel Andrades
BISHOP HENRY UNABLE TO RESPOND TO HERESY CHARGES
Bishop Frederick Henry does not deny heresy charge
BISHOP FREDERICK HENRY AND THE SSPX INTERPRET VATICAN COUNCIL II AS BREAK WITH THE PAST : THEY ASSUME THE DEAD ARE VISIBLE AS DID THE ARCHBISHOP OF BOSTON RICHARD CUSHING
BISHOP FREDRICK HENRY OF CALGARY,CANADA RESPONDS: SSPX
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment