There is a comment on this blog.It is regarding the post in which I said there are two interpretations of Vatican Council II.
It says:
-J Daniels
August 1, 2013 at 5:10 PM
Lionel:
No it is not a personal interpretation.
I am pointing out that one can choose to interpret Vatican Council II by using a particular premise or without that premise. In this way there are always two interpretations.
It has nothing to do with me or my views.
It is the same text for all but it can be interpreted with the Richard Cushing Error or without it.
Assume the dead now saved in Heaven are visible to us on earth and so are an exception to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus or assume that they are not visible to us and so are not exceptions. This is independent of me.
So assume LG 16 refers to being saved in invincible ignorance which is visible or it refers to cases not visible to us and so which are not an exception to the dogmatic teaching which says all need to convert into the Church.So there can be two interpretations but only one rational one.
There are presently two interpretations since most Catholics,including the Vatican Curia are using the irrational one, they can allegedly see the dead.
I am pointing out that one can choose to interpret Vatican Council II by using a particular premise or without that premise. In this way there are always two interpretations.
It has nothing to do with me or my views.
It is the same text for all but it can be interpreted with the Richard Cushing Error or without it.
Assume the dead now saved in Heaven are visible to us on earth and so are an exception to the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus or assume that they are not visible to us and so are not exceptions. This is independent of me.
So assume LG 16 refers to being saved in invincible ignorance which is visible or it refers to cases not visible to us and so which are not an exception to the dogmatic teaching which says all need to convert into the Church.So there can be two interpretations but only one rational one.
There are presently two interpretations since most Catholics,including the Vatican Curia are using the irrational one, they can allegedly see the dead.
-Lionel Andrades
There can be two interpretations of Vatican Council II Lumen Fidei has chosen the irrational one.
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2013/07/there-can-be-two-interpretations-of.html#links
Archbishop Gerhard Muller says that the SSPX needs to distinguish the true teaching of the Second Vatican Council: but he will not correct Reuters.
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2012/12/archbishop-gerhard-muller-says-that.html#links
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment