Sunday, August 17, 2014

Reconciliation with the SSPX


Lay Catholics friends of the SSPX must come to their assistance now.Do not let an irrational interpretation of Vatican Council II accepted by all camps, be an obstacle to their entering into the Church with full canonical status.
The Society of St,.Pius X (SSPX) priests and leadership are afraid to admit that there is a a rational interpretation of the Council and it is in accord with Sacred Tradition.
Lay Catholics, friends of the SSPX must not allow the progessivists to take advantage  of this general ignorance.
There is is one simple step required for this reconciliation.It is this.
The SSPX must admit that all salvation in Heaven is not physically visible and known to us in 2014.These persons are seen and known only to God.
Now with this rational statement, appeal to the SSPX to do theology and philosophy.
Also ask them to have the integrity to answer questions about the Catholic Faith and to admit when they are irrational and wrong.
Ask Bishop Bernard Fellay and the SSPX priests how can they imply that Nostra Aetate 2( saved with a ray of the Truth)  is an exception to Tradition? (Do they know any case in 2014 ? Does Vatican Council II say that these cases are known to us? Does Vatican Council II say that these cases are an exception to extra ecclesiam nulla salus?)
Ask them to answer these questions clearly and in public and not say 'Fr.Feeney said this ' or that  'Pope Pius XII said that'.
Assuming Fr.Feeney was wrong ( and he was not) or that he was correct, how is Nostra Aeatte 2  and exception to extra ecclesiam nulla salus?



Lay Catholics who use this reasoning with the SSPX will find that there is nothing in Vatican Council II to contradict extra ecclesiam nulla salus.
It's just that the priests, bishops and cardinals within and outside  the SSPX,do not want to affirm extra ecclesiam ulla salus.They do not want to affirm extra ecclesiam nulla salus in accord with Vatican Council II.
Those lay Catholics who want a reconciliation of the SSPX, and a reconciliation with sane doctrine,should appeal to the SSPX and get a reply from them.Cristopher Ferrara is avoiding a comment on this issue and so is Mons.Ignacio Barreiro, Drr.John Rao and correspondents of the Rorate Caili.
I accept Vatican Council II without the dead are visible premise .I do not assume that these deceased are explicit for us or that they are exceptions to extra ecclesiam nulla salus. The SSPX does not agree with me and neither do they disagree with me.
-Lionel Andrades 
-

No comments: