April 8, 2018
Fr.Paul McDonald is really saying he supports an exclusivist ecclesiology with no dual conclusions, heterodox passages, no passages against EENS
When Fr.Paul McDonald said 'Even
Vatican Council II says every one on the face of the earth is called to
become a member of the Mystical Body(The Catholic Church)' it means
there is exclusive salvation in the Catholic Church, every one needs to
be Catholic to go to Heaven.This is Vatican Council II.
VATICAN COUNCIL II HAVING ORTHODOX AND HETERODOX PASSAGES INDICATES CUSHINGISM
VATICAN COUNCIL II HAVING ORTHODOX AND HETERODOX PASSAGES INDICATES CUSHINGISM
For me the Council only says all need to enter the Church and it does not say that there are exceptions.There is no dual reading of Vatican Council II.No orthodox and heterodox passages for me.There are no for and against extra ecclesiam nulla salus (EENS) passages in Vatican Council, for me.
This is a very important point to note. Since most people err here.
A FALSE PREMISE CREATES THE DUAL APPROACH IN READING VATICAN COUNCIL II
A FALSE PREMISE CREATES THE DUAL APPROACH IN READING VATICAN COUNCIL II
Most people use the dual approach in the interpretation.It's Yes and No, orthodox and heterodox, for and against EENS.
This comes about by using a false premise.This is how the seemingly unorthodox passages are created.
ALLEGED HETERODOX PASSAGES IN VATICAN COUNCIL II ARE HYPOTHETICAL FOR ME
ALLEGED HETERODOX PASSAGES IN VATICAN COUNCIL II ARE HYPOTHETICAL FOR ME
For
me Vatican Council II only affirms the exclusive ecclesiology of
salvation in the Catholic Church. Since the allegedly heterodox passages are hypothetical for me. So they are not exceptions to EENS.Rationally
they cannot be anything else.The baptism of desire and being saved in
invincible ignorance for example can only be a hypothetical case for us
humans.
FEENEYITE WAY OF READING VATICAN COUNCIL II
FEENEYITE WAY OF READING VATICAN COUNCIL II
The
hypothetical passages in LG 8, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc are not
exceptions to EENS in 2018.This I call the Feeneyite way of reading
Vatican Council II.With the Feeneyite approach Vatican Council II is
saying, solely, 'every one on the face of the earth is called to become a member of the Mystical Body'(AG 7).
MAGISTERIUM USES THE FOR AND AGAINST METHOD TO READ VATICAN COUNCIL II
MAGISTERIUM USES THE FOR AND AGAINST METHOD TO READ VATICAN COUNCIL II
But this is not how the present Magisterium reads Vatican Council II.They use the for and against EENS method instead of the for and neutral to EENS method so there is a rupture with Tradition. With the for and neutral to EENS approach the 'controversial' passages would not be unorthodox or even relevant to EENS.
The
for and against EENS method is created, I repeat, by assuming
references to hypotheticals are non hypothetical but instead objective
in the present times.
So
there are the orthodox passages which support EENS and the
'unorthodox passages' which are interpreted as being exceptions to EENS.
This I call Cushingism.
CUSHINGISM CONSIDERS ORTHODOX PASSAGES AS REFERRING TO OBJECTIVE PEOPLE
CUSHINGISM CONSIDERS ORTHODOX PASSAGES AS REFERRING TO OBJECTIVE PEOPLE
Cushingism
considers the 'unorthodox passages' in Vatican Council II as referring
to explicit cases while Feeneyism considers them to be just hypothetical
cases only.This is a crucial point. Here it is where the road forks and
most people take the wrong turn.
SEEMINGLY HETERODOX PASSAGES ARE NOT EXCEPTIONS TO THE ORTHODOX PASSAGES FOR ME
SEEMINGLY HETERODOX PASSAGES ARE NOT EXCEPTIONS TO THE ORTHODOX PASSAGES FOR ME
When I read what is commonly
considered 'the heterodox passages' they are neither heterodox nor
exceptions to the orthodox passages. I just brush them off as being
hypothetical.Hypotheticals cannot be real and concrete examples of
salvation outside the Church in 2018.
FR. PAUL MCDONALD AFFIRMS THE OLD ECCLESIOLOGY
FR. PAUL MCDONALD AFFIRMS THE OLD ECCLESIOLOGY
So without 'the heterodox passages', the hypotheticals coming in his way Fr. Paul McDonald
would be saying 'Even Vatican Council II says every one on the face of
the earth is called to become a member of the Mystical Body(The Catholic
Church)' there are no practical exceptions in 2018 and none mentioned
in the Council text.None.
Mission doctrine today is the same as that of the Jesuits in the 16th century when Vatican Council II is interpreted with Feeneyism instead of the common and irrational Cushingism.There is no known salvation outside the Church to contract the 16th century exclusivist ecclesiology.
Mission doctrine today is the same as that of the Jesuits in the 16th century when Vatican Council II is interpreted with Feeneyism instead of the common and irrational Cushingism.There is no known salvation outside the Church to contract the 16th century exclusivist ecclesiology.
This
is the rational interpretation of Vatican Council II.It is
premise-free. The Council II can really only be Feeneyite and a
Cushingite interpretation does not make sense.It is irrational. How can
people in Heaven be visible exceptions to the dogma EENS on earth ? How
can invisible people on earth be visible exceptions to the past
exclusivist ecclesiology of the Church? If someone does not exist how
can be relevant to EENS as an exception?
REDEMPTORIS MISSIO AND DOMINUS WERE CUSHINGITE
REDEMPTORIS MISSIO AND DOMINUS WERE CUSHINGITE
So
when we read Vatican Council II we can choose to see the exclusivist
ecclesiology or a general Christology.In Redemptoris Missio and Dominus
Iesus, Cardinal Ratzinger chose an ecumenical Christology and rejected
the past exclusivist ecclesiology.
We do not reject the Christology and nor the exclusivist ecclesiology of Vatican Council II.-Lionel Andrades
APRIL 7, 2018
NOVEMBER 18, 2016
The two Catholic political organisations are Forza Nuova and Militia Christi. These two lay organisations should be supported in some way this feast of Christ the King
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2016/11/on-sunday-is-feast-of-christ-king-we.html
Catholic political parties and lay Catholics can first affirm the dogma EENS and then the Social Reign of Christ the King.In this way Catholics can enter in an organised way into the politics of France without any confusion in doctrine and theology :Macron's appeal to Catholics
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2018/04/catholic-political-parties-and-lay.html
JULY 17, 2017
Catholic political parties must teach Catholics the faith which is not being taught by religious due to political pressure
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2017/07/catholic-political-parties-must-teach.html
What if the pope or Bishop Fellay called for a day to celebrate and discuss the Social Reign of Christ the King over all political legislation ?
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2018/04/what-if-pope-or-bishop-fellay-called.html
Even Vatican II says every one on the face of the earth is called to become a member of the Mystical Body ( the Catholic Church)- Fr.Paul McDonald , Fatima Center http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2018/04/even-vatican-ii-says-every-one-on-face.html
MAY 22, 2018
Repost : Catholic political party needed in England
http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2018/05/repost-catholic-political-party-needed.html
A Catholic political party is needed to oppose Satan and leftist fascism and extremism http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2018/04/a-catholic-political-party-is-needed-to.html
AUGUST 17, 2017
Bishops Fellay, Schneider are not proclaiming the Social Reign of Christ the King supported by Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite) http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.it/2017/08/bishops-fellay-schneider-are-not.html
No comments:
Post a Comment