It is unfortunate that young Catholics in Germany, have to re-interpret Vatican Council II,in an irrational and compromised version to keep the German church away from schism

The young people at the Acies Ordinata prayer assembly in Munich, last Saturday against the 'schismatic' Cardinal Reinhardt Marx, Archbishop of Munich, could be in contact with priests  who teach at the pontifical universities or the Society of St.Pius X seminary or one of the sedevacantist seminaries, where all the books interpret Vatican Council II, with a false premise to create a rupture with Tradition.

This is common.

Even if they read books on Vatican Council II written by Plineo Correa de Oliveriera, Fr.Nicholas Gruner, Chris Ferrara or Roberto dei Mattei, they will find all  interpreted irrationally.They are Cushingite and not Feeneyite.All the books published by Oxford University, Amazon or Ignatius Press are in this category of error
 

There has also been no article written by John Henry Weston in which Vatican Council II was interpreted without the false premise and so  was projected as being in harmony with extra ecclesiam nulla salus.

Those young people were probably taught in Religion/Catechism Class that every one needs to enter the Catholic Church for salvation except for....

Or, the Church is necessary for salvation but every one does not need to enter for salvation, there are exceptions, example...

They probably do not know that there is a Vatican Council II without a false premise and inference, there is a Vatican Council II,Feeneyite and Cardinal Marx does not like it.

If Cardinal Marx was told to accept and announce a Vatican Council II Feeneyite,instead of the present Vatican Council II, Cushingite, he would puff hard on his cigar.

If Cardinal Marx affirmed Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite) he would lose his support among influential international organizations.They would demand that he step down as a cardinal.Since Cushingism and Feeneyism are the real political issue and not just Vatican Council II.

But assuming Pope Francis and Pope Benedict were honest and for some reason were forced to say that they affirm Vatican Council II( Feeneyite), then Cardinal Reinhardt Marx and the German bishops would not like it.They may decide to leave the Church and call themselves schismatics or sedevacantists, unless the two popes came back to Vatican Council II (Cushingite).

Similarly if some of the German bishops affirmed Vatican Council II ( Feeneyite) they would then also be saying there can only be an EENS ( Feeneyite).This is rational.If Cardinal Marx supported them, he would be in schism for the Left.

So now like the professors at the Catholic seminaries and universities in Germany,everyone affirms Vatican Council II ( Cushingite) and there is no schism in the Church from the Left.But it is unfortunate that young Catholics in Germany, have to re-interpret Vatican Council II,in an irrational and compromised version to keep the German church away from schism.-Lionel Andrades 


 https://www.ncregister.com/blog/edward-pentin/munich-protest-requests-clarity-and-coherence-from-pope-francis-german-bish