The publishers of Pope Benedict's books in German must note that he used a false premise and inference to interpret Vatican Council II as a break with Tradition and this is not only bad philosophy and bad theology it is unethical and dishonest.
Vatican Council II can be interpreted without the false premise and inference and the conclusion would support the past ecclesiology, 16th century extra ecclesiam nulla salus(EENS) and the traditional ecumenism of return. But this interpretation is no way there in any of the German pope's books published by private publishers and the Vatican Publishing House.
There are numerous books published by different publishers expressing Pope Benedict's theology and thought. With the false premise Pope Benedict has changed the understanding of the Nicene and Apostles Creed and made the Athanasius Creed obsolete.This is first class heresy.
Pope Paul VI too had a choice. He could have interpreted Vatican Council II rationally and in harmony with Tradition ( Athanasius Creed, Catechism of Pope Pius X etc).German publishers need to be informed that this interpretation of Vatican Council II is deceptive and subterfuge. A correction and apology is due from Joseph Raztinger.-Lionel Andrades
Die
Ekklesiologie der Konstitution Lumen
gentium - Joseph
Cardinal Ratzinger - Benedictus XVI
http://ivv7srv15.uni-muenster.de/mnkg/pfnuer/Ratzinger-Kirche-Lumen-Gentium.html
The former Archbishop of Munich's books published by Ignatius Press have
an in- principle error.The German Joseph Ratzinger's books were written
with an irrational premise to create an artificial rupture with
Tradition on Vatican Council II, the Catechism of the Catholic Church,
the Nicene Creed and other magisterial documents.There should be an
apology from Pope Benedict and Ignatius Press. https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2020/01/the-former-archbishop-of-munichs-books.html
Cardinal Reinhardt Marx needs to review the books on Vatican Council II
in Germany. They have a built-in error.New books need to be written on
the Council
https://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2020/01/cardinal-reinhardt-marx-needs-to-review.html
News
agency reports of the past on Vatican Council II need to be corrected
officially by Cardinal Reinhardt Marx and German News Agencies and also
the Federal Press Conference Association (BPK-Bundespressekonferenz)
Questions and Answers
When
the popes and the traditionalists use a false premise and inference to
interpret the Council it is not just another opinion or theology, it is
subterfuge. It is telling a lie officially
No comments:
Post a Comment