It's the false premise which creates the hermeneutic of rupture with Tradition and not Vatican Council II per se.This is new information. When someone criticizes the traditionalists, it shows that he does not understand how the false premise works. He needs to be shown how he would emerge a traditionalist if he did not use the false premise

It's the false premise which creates the hermeneutic of rupture with Tradition and not Vatican Council II per se.This is new information.

When someone criticizes  the traditionalists, it shows that he does not understand how the false premise works. He needs to be shown how he would emerge a traditionalist if he did not use the false premise. -Lionel Andrades