Dr.Joseph Shaw interprets Vatican Council II with a false premise.So he is not a Radical Traditionalists for the liberal bishops of Britain. But if he interpreted Vatican Council II and EENS without the false premise he would be a RT and may be not allowed to teach at the Benedictines St.Benet Hall, Oxford. The Benedictines and Dominicans at Oxford are not RTs since they use the false premise.

 

Dr.Joseph Shaw interprets Vatican Council II with a false premise.So he is not a Radical Traditionalists for the liberal bishops of Britain.

But if he interpreted Vatican Council II and EENS without the false premise he would be a RT and may be not allowed to teach at the Benedictines St.Benet Hall, Oxford.

The Benedictines and Dominicans at Oxford are not RTs since they use the false premise. -Lionel Andrades