Like Church Militant TV, LifeSites News would want to protect its financial interests as does the Lepanto Foundation : so it hides the truth about the Catholic Faith

Diane Montagna did an interview with Prof.Roberto dei Mattei sometime back for LifeSitesNews on the conference(June 23,2018).
Today she could ask Prof. Mattei or  Dr.Robert Shaw if it  is true that they use a false premise to interpret Vatican Council II as a rupture with Tradition.They do this in principle, in general, as usual.

There will probably be no denial.

There could be two responses from the speakers and organizers. One response to LifeSitesNews  could  be, "Yes  Diane, we do use a false premise(baptism of desire(LG 14) refers to known people saved outside the Church) to interpret Vatican Council II.So in this way there is a rupture with the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus ( Feeneyite). With the false premise we have extra ecclesiam nulla salus( Cushingite).It would be saying that there is known salvation outside the Church.So since there is 'an unknown possibility',which we assume is an actual person in real life, a known non Catholic, saved outside the Church, we reason ( badly) that every body does not need to enter the Church as a member in 2018."

Or the other response of the organizers to LifeSitesNews could be,"No, Diane, we do not use the false premise to interpret Vatican Council.Lionel is wrong.The baptism of desire(LG 14) refers to an unknown and invisible non Catholic saved outside the Church in 2018. So there is no rupture with the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus ( Feeneyite). Without  the false premise we have extra ecclesiam nulla salus( Feeneyite).It  means, there is no known salvation outside the Church.So since the theoretical possibility of a non Catholic being saved outside the Church is not a reality, every body does need to enter the Church as a member in 2018.This  is the dogmatic teaching.It is extra ecclesiam nulla salus, supported by Vatican Council II (AG 7, LG 14).The ordinary way of salvation is faith and baptism.It is the norm. The norm is not the baptism of desire etc .So are Feeneyites on extra ecclesiam nulla salus, Vatican Council II, the Catechisms and other magisterial documents".

She could then ask them if they would be ready to  interpret LG 8, LG14, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2 etc without the false premise,i.e with hypothetical cases just being hypothetical,with Feeneyism.They are not objectively known people saved outside the Church in 2018.There cannot be any known Catholics saved outside the Church.
Prof. Mattei and every one in all his medias would refuse to answer.

She would then ask politely, "But are you'll not being irrational ?".

Roberto dei Mattei,Joseph Shaw and John Lamont would refuse to answer. In fact all those who signed the Correction of Pope Francis, with Dr.Joseph Shaw as their spokesman, refused to answer. They were not interested in this doctrine of the Catholic Church which was changed a long time back.

Joseph Shaw would respond to Dr. Robert Fastiggi but not to the posts on Lionel's Blog.They would be 'too sensitive' for him.

"So it is upon this philosophical and theological deception that another conference is being organized by the traditionalists?", Diane Montagna  could dare to ask. The organizers would have to say "YES" or keep quiet and change the subject.

"So you all are allowing Catholics in general and traditionalists in particular, to interpret Vatican Council II with Cushingism instead of Feeneyism,with a false premise instead of without it, since otherwise, the Council would be in harmony with the past exclusivist ecclesiology of the Church, which you'll do not want to affirm in public for personal reasons ?

There will be no answer from the organizers of the conference.

But how can LifeSitesNews discuss this issue ? How can Diane Montagna be allowed to ask these questions?

It has been years now - that John Henry Western and Steve Jalsevec to protect their own interests, do not  interpret Vatican Council II and EENS with Feeneyism i.e with hypothetical cases just being hypothetical.

They prefer the irrationality and the heresy.They prefer doctrines being changed. Since this is not an issue like Amoris Laetitia. They will be opposing the Jewish Left on this issue.
So like Church Militant TV, LifeSites News wants to protect its financial interests as does the Lepanto Foundation.
-Lionel Andrades

JUNE 10, 2018

John Lamont and Joseph Shaw prepare to talk at the June 23 Lepanto Foundation conference in Rome with their politically correct Cushingite theology, which will preserve their careers and lifestyle and they will get away with it to come back next year

http://eucharistandmission.blogspot.com/2018/06/john-lamont-and-joseph-shaw-prepare-to.html