Angelus Press of the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) sell books with misinformation on Vatican Council II. The most recent is a A layman's Guide to Vatican Council II by Fr. Arnaud De Lassus who interprets the Council with a false premise and inference.
This error is not just an opinion on the Council but it is a lie.It is deception.The SSPX bishops have been informoed about this unethical activity, over the last few years but will not comment.
The Angelus Press Home Page has this review of the new book.
The Layman’s Guide to Vatican II is a summary of the need-to-know essentials from the Second Vatican Council. It offers a concise outline of events, an explanation of the Council origins and a breakdown of its key documents. Using accessible language, it proceeds with astounding clarity to define and explain each of the errors of Vatican II.
Lionel: Angelus Press is referring to the eror of Vatican Council II when the Council is interpreted with LG 8, LG 14, LG 16, UR 3, NA 2, GS 22 etc as referring to objective exceptions to the past exclusivist ecclesiology of the Church, an ecumenism of return and 16th century extra ecclesiam nulla salus.
There is no mention of the possibility of the Council being interpreted with LG 8 etc as referring to only hypothetical cases in 1965-2020.So they are not exceptions to Tradition ( Syllabus of Errors, Athanasius Creed etc).
_____________
- Topics of interest for the curious Catholic:
- History of Vatican II
- Documents produced by Vatican II
- What are Religious Liberty, Collegiality, and Ecumenism
With the past ecclesiology intact Collegiality would not be an issue.Since there would be unity on doctrine.
Also in a Catholic State which affirms EENS and the past ecclesiology, non Catholics would still be free to follow their religions, as during the time of the papal states and the Austro Hungarian Catholic Empire.The ethos of the Constitution would be Catholic, Jesus as he is known and followed in the Catholic Church, would be the center of all social and political legislation.
Protestant-inspired shift from a God-focused Church to a man-focused Church
Lionel: This would be possible only with Vatican Council II interpreted irrationally.
_______________________
Lionel: There is only a departure when Vatican Council II is interpreted by confusing what is hypothetical as being objective and known in the present times. This is irrational.
_____________________
This brief, easy-to-read text is an aid for Catholics to better understand Vatican II and today’s modern crisis. If you’re looking for quick access to the facts, or simply trying to help others understand what really happened at the Second Vatican Council, this book is for you!
Angelus Press owned by the Society of St.Pius X(SSPX) has published a book Roberto dei Mattei's book on Vatican Council II.He mistakenly interpreted Vatican Council II with a false premise and then criticized the Council. He did not interpret the Council without the error and so affirm Feeneyite EENS and the past ecclesiocentric ecclesiology of the Catholic Church.1
Fr. Laisney book, Is Feeneyism Catholic? superficially and irrationally interprets BOD, BOB and I.I and Vatican Council and then slanders Fr. Leonard Feeney and the St.Benedict Centers in the USA.
The SSPX website also has a section, Feeneyism .They have accepted the bad reasoning of the Letter of the Holy Office 1949(LOHO).The same error was made by Pope Pius XII and Pope John XXIII. Then the popes from Paul VI repeated it on Vatican Council II.
Angelus Press has published 'Is Feeneyism Catholic' by Fr.Francois Laisney and the Second Vatican Council II and Unwritten Story by Roberto dei Mattei,based on a factual and objective error in the interpretation of Vatican Council II and other magisterial documents.This is part of the religious formation of the SSPX seminarians. 2
They need to admit it.An apology from Angelus Press is expected.They need to caution writers to not send manuscrpts with Vatican Council II interpreted with the false premise.-Lionel Andrades
1
JANUARY 25, 2020
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment